TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Details Emerge on Graves' Firing: DOJ Told Different Stories to Graves and Sen. Bond

Eleven months before seven US Attorneys were fired on December 7th, 2006, former Kansas City US Attorney Todd Graves received a call from an official at the Executive Office for the U.S. Attorney telling him he was fired. Graves announced his resignation less than two months later on March 10.

Justice Department officials would later tell Sen. Kit Bond (R-MO) that Graves had been dismissed for "performance" issues, according to Wednesday article in the Kansas City Star. But that's not what Graves was told at the time. According to a source with detailed knowledge of the conversation, Graves was told that his removal was not based on his performance as a prosecutor, but that it was simply time to let someone else have a chance at the job.

That someone, of course, turned out to be Bradley Schlozman, Graves' successor as US Attorney and the first US Attorney to be appointed using the special powers granted the Attorney General in the revised version of the USA Patriot Act signed into law in March 2006.

Contacted today by TPMMuckraker.com, a Justice Department spokesman declined to comment on Graves' dismissal, but Graves' case resembles those of at least two other fired prosecutors whose dismissals have been tied to complaints from Republican party officials that they did not press vote fraud indictments against Democrats.

According to the same knowledgeable source, over the last four years, Graves, a Republican himself, had two flaps with the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department.

The first, dating back to 2002, was not voting-rights related, but involved a cross-burning case where Graves helped negotiate a civil mediation. Graves hung up on the head of the Civil Rights Division at the time over a disagreement about the terms of the settlement.

In 2005, Graves again clashed with the Civil Rights Division when he declined to sign a letter outlining a voter-registration lawsuit against the State of Missouri pushed by Bradley Schlozman, then an assistant attorney general in charge of the Voting Section of the Civil Rights Division.

The suit alleged that Missouri was not being sufficiently aggressive in purging its vote rolls of out of date or ineligible registrations. Graves allegedly dragged his feet during the lead-up to the lawsuit’s filing and was openly dubious about whether the case would ultimately prove successful.

After the firing, at Graves' request, Missouri's senior Senator Kit Bond placed a call to the White House to briefly extend Graves’ time in office, a Bond spokeswoman said in a statement yesterday. But Bond’s request was denied.


51 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

OKI doki. Poor plight of an attorney who tried to play ball with a chickenshit administration who won't even value party loyalty
I don't really feel his pain, but understand how loyal party member feel a tad disregarded.

user-pic

PBS has a series on the Inquisition.

Is it deja vu "all over again?"

What a "waste!"

user-pic

Nothing to see here, move along now...

Well, well, the man obviously didn't understand that the Party sets the prosecution agendas.

We all know that the corruption is pervasive and probably drove every action within the DOJ.
It's time to stop following all of the fall out from this corruption and instead start climbing up the tentacles that lead to the White House.

Continuing to accumulate all of these individual results just overwhelms the real purpose which is to tie this back to the WH. Let's stay focused on what is important.

user-pic

Scary, isn't it? Seemingly intelligent US Attorneys...and yet, they all voted for Bush and Cheney.

That's the part I have trouble getting around.

user-pic

WHY? do we hear NOTHING else about Sen. Spector's roll in all of this. It was HIS OFFICE that PROVIDED the law which ALLOWED this mess in the first place.

You don't have to be a blind conservative not to see it, just an ignorant one to deny it.

user-pic

I think the question is, is it more important to uphold the Constitution by using the impeachment process to remove a totally corrupt administration, or is it better to keep them in office constantly on the defensive for two years? The former is certainly the best move if you want to maintain the ability to use the impeachment procedure for anything but political hard ball. But, doing that gives the new President, most likely a Republican, a big lead for the 2008 election. (If both Bush and Cheney are impeached, one resigns, the other appoints a replacemtne, who becomes president.) I don't have an answer yet.

user-pic

Regarding Specter: At the very least the public must inquire how often "aides" stick stuff into US Law without oversight.

user-pic

Specter is the dog that didn't bark now isn't he. When is the last time you heard him say anything at all close to defending the AG or the administration? He now knows how thoroughly rotten the whole deal is and he also knows he himself may be in the cross-hairs on the Patriot Act treachery.

user-pic

According to PACER, the DOJ complaint against Missouri Secretary of State Robin Carnahan was filed on 11/22/05. Within two months, Todd Graves was fired.

I linked to the DOJ complaint below. Bradley Shlozman's name is not on it but I don't know if that is unusual.

Former USA-WDMO Bradley Schlozman's 11/1/06 press release announcing the indictment of the ACORN Four has been deleted from the USA-WDMO's archive of 2006 press releases:

http://www.usdoj.gov/usao/mow/pr/news2006.html

I think it would be worthwhile to ask Schlozman about how much contact he and his office had with the American Center For Voting Rights, founded in March 2005 by Mark "Thor" Hearne and other GOP operatives.

Hearne's bio:

"Mark F. (Thor) Hearne, II is a member and principal of the Lathrop & Gage law firm [St. Louis]and serves on the firm's government relations committee. Hearne is General Counsel to the American Center for Voting Rights (ACVR) and serves as a member of the organization's Board of Directors.

Prior to joining ACVR, Hearne served as National Election Counsel to Bush-Cheney ?04 and Missouri counsel to Bush-Cheney '00. Hearne has also served as General Counsel to Missouri Governor Blunt, and was appointed by then Secretary of State Blunt as an advisor for the implementation of the Help America Vote Act (HAVA). Hearne testified before the Missouri commission established by Blunt to investigate the 2000 Missouri general election and voter fraud in the city of St. Louis..."

From the now-defunct American Center For Voting Rights website:

"March 21, 2005

ACVR Refers Voter Fraud Investigation To Department of Justice, Congressional Oversight Panel

Report Shows Third Party Effort to Circumvent Law and Register Illegal Voters

Contact: Jim Dyke, 843/722-9670

COLUMBUS, OHIO - Today the American Center for Voting Rights (ACVR) referred a compendium of preliminary findings of registration fraud, intimidation, vote fraud and litigation to the U.S. Department of Justice. The report was previously made available to the House Administration Committee who will hold a field hearing on election fraud in Columbus today..."

user-pic

Congrats om the scoop, Ms. McGann.

user-pic

Here's another possible reason to get rid of Graves. From a link in today's Muckraker Delay story, three dead AUSA's in Texas concerning:

"...the Justice Department's (DOJ) inquiry into healthcare industry purchasing, antitrust issues and other Medicare abuses.

..

"...and three fired Texas assistant U.S attorneys and fired U.S. attorneys Carol Lam of San Diego and Todd Graves of Kansas City, all of whom were probing Novation LLC and its members.

...

"Attorney General Alberto Gonzales was a partner in Vinson & Elkins, LLP which represents defendant Novation"

http://tomflocco.com/fs/DeathsFoulPlayQuestions.htm

user-pic

Ms. McGann, way to fight! You write 'em, I'll read 'em. That is to say, I'll read 'em here first.

user-pic

FRONT page ... Washington Post tomorrow.

Number of Fired US Attorneys Grows ...

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/05/09/AR2007050902718.html

Way to GO, Muckracker!

user-pic

These Republican politicians are what get me. They still vote lock step with what the president wants- even after the White House repeatedly lied to them and Bush's approval ratings are dragging them down as well.
Code Word: crush
As in crush the GOP from here on out.

user-pic

Gonzales and the other DOJ officials who said only 8 were fired- well now that we know there were at least 9 then they committed perjury right?

user-pic

Holy shit. I sure hope the Dems are livid because the DOJ has repeatedly given them a big FUCK YOU! Check this out from the Washington Post article linked above:
"The same month he was asked to step down, Graves's name was included in a Jan. 9, 2006, list assembled by Gonzales's then-chief of staff, D. Kyle Sampson, of seven U.S. attorneys the administration was considering forcing from their jobs. That April, Sampson sent another e-mail noting that two of the prosecutors on that list had already left. Three names, including Graves's, were redacted when Justice officials released the January list."

user-pic

Hoppy,if Bush and Cheney are both gone, the Speaker of the House becomes acting president! That's right: Nancy Pelosi! And that really has Repugnicans soiling their khakis.

sc: keep. Keep it up, TPM. The snowball is starting to roll down the hill and it gets bigger and bigger and bigger . . .

user-pic

More from the Washington Post:
"Now a lawyer for the Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys, Schlozman was tentatively scheduled to testify next Tuesday before the Senate Judiciary Committee. But Justice and legislative aides said yesterday that Schlozman has requested more time to prepare his testimony."
HELL NO! No more time- stop playing the White house stall game Dems! I'm sick of the pussyfooting around. Pick up the pace! We've still got the Interior Department, EPA, FDA and other agencies to expose. Trace this shit back to Rove in the next two months and let's move on to the other crooked bastards. And don't think we've forgot about you Lurita Doan, you crooked Rovian Hatch Act violator. You're not gonna get a free pass. So many crooks, so little time.
Code word: step
As in step up the pace!

user-pic

When Gonzo got the call about this this evening he sat up in bed and shouted "Aye Caramba!!!!!!!!!"

user-pic

good job!
If it is now impartially being called 9 USAs, some people have committed perjury, no?

user-pic

Judicial Watchdog Demands Commission On AG Alberto Gonzales Promotion Of Bradley Schlozman After Schlozman’s Voting Rights Act Violations:

http://www.1888pressrelease.com/judicial-watchdog-demands-commission-on-ag-alberto-gonzales-pr-9ueg517q5.html

user-pic

First one Big Attaway To Go Ms.McGann !Second sure wish we could get the MSM to give TPM more credit for these ""gets" that keep coming from your site. Heck Racheal Maddeaux was on Olbermann the other night-and might as well been channeling TPM without nary an acknowlegement.
And I have been saying loudly ,a good long while , that the TurdBlossom Grand Plan had pissed off way to many good, law abiding ,career federal employees for the BushCo not to be ratted out to the Democratically controlled Congress,
And yes the Impeachment train has left the Station - President Pelosi does have a nice ring to it- does it not !! (Remember kids it wasn't Watergate that got Nixon -it was the endless War in Vietnam- history does repeat itself - Watergate was just the vehicle for Tricky Dick's removal )

user-pic

I second what Al in Austex just said. Where the hell is the credit to TPM in the MSM reporting? WTF.

user-pic

According to a source with detailed knowledge of the conversation, Graves was told that his removal was not based on his performance as a prosecutor, but that it was simply time to let someone else have a chance at the job.

Interesting to learn that the one who deserved to be given a chance to gain experience at this type of job was Bradley Schlozman, who, among all those who deserved to be given such a chance, was then an assistant attorney general in charge of the Voting Section of the Civil Rights Division!

Interesting also is to learn that once he got a stab at this new job (read mission accomplished), he was right back in Washington……

Does one even consider moving there for such a short time, if it were not to execute a mission? Did he intend to spend some time there, or was his return to Washington arranged in advance?

These are some of the questions that should be asked… Did the DOJ really reserve this position as a training post for career employees? If so, then did Schlozman really need to gain this type of experience?

user-pic

This may have a parallel with what happened in the Northern District of Iowa. When the incumbent US attorney (Charles Larson Sr) retired, he was replaced by his FAUSA (Judith Whetstine) who received an "Acting" appointment.
27 days later, Whetstine (who is married to a former Democratic candidate for congress) had retired, and replaced by "loyal Bushie" Matt Dummermuth.

In a phone conversation I had last week with Whetstine, she indicated that neither her nor Larson's retirement was "political" -- she stayed on after Larson left only because an "interim" USA was not ready to be appointed. However, Whetstine also indicated that she had offered to stay on for a short period to ease the transition in that office -- and her offer was turned down. (Ordinarily, one would assume that a new USA would jump at the chance to keep the FAUSA around for a couple of months to maintain continuity in the office.)

user-pic

Two comments.

1) Did the call to Graves precede the 'secret order' document? If DOJ did call to kick him out before the 1st secret order memo was written, what are the implication's? Was a law broken?

2) There is a parallel timeline with all of these fired USA's for 'voter fraud'. The polling numbers of the Incumbent vs. Democratic challengers should be considered. Does anyone know if McCaskill (sp?) was really doing well in Missouri senate race back in Dec of '05 to early Jan '06 timeframe? That would have been about the time Rove would have decided to remove the USA to help the incumbent.

user-pic

Who gave Graves the infamous phone call?

From the Seattle Times yesterday
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/nationworld/2003700902_attorneys10.html

Graves said he got a phone call shortly after Jan. 1, 2006, from Michael Battle, then director of the department's Executive Office for United States Attorneys. Graves said Battle told him that department officials wanted to change leadership in the Kansas City office, emphasizing "there are no performance issues."

user-pic

Remember what Battle said under sworn testimony?
http://mediamatters.org/items/200704160005

The article noted that Gonzales "is certain to be asked on Tuesday about his own recollection of events" and that "Michael A. Battle, the former director of the department's United States attorney liaison office," has apparently contradicted Gonzales' claim that he "was not involved in seeing any memos," and "was not involved in any discussions about" the dismissals. However, according to Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-NY), Battle -- the official who informed the U.S. attorneys that they were to be fired -- told the committee that shortly before the firings, he was unaware of "performance problems" with all but one of the fired U.S. attorneys, even though Gonzales has claimed that the prosecutors were dismissed for performance reasons. By contrast, The Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, the Chicago Tribune, and the Associated Press all reported Schumer's statements about Battle.

....

Battle told investigators that he was "not aware of performance problems with respect to several" of the prosecutors, until just days before he called to fire them, Schumer said in a conference call with reporters yesterday. Aides later said that Battle, whose job was to supervise the department's 93 U.S. attorneys, was aware of performance-related issues only with Kevin Ryan, the U.S. attorney for San Francisco.

Schumer said Battle also contradicted Gonzales's assertion at a March 13 news conference that he had not seen any documents or participated in any discussions about the firings. A memo related to the dismissals was passed out at a Nov. 27 meeting attended by Gonzales and others, Battle told investigators.

"Mike Battle remembers a memo was distributed," Schumer said.

Similarly, an April 16 Los Angeles Times article noted, "Schumer told reporters that Michael Battle, former head of the Justice Department office that oversees U.S. attorneys, knew nothing about any performance problems of several of those who were fired until shortly before he was directed to call them Dec. 7 and tell them they were being removed." An April 16 Associated Press report also stated that "Battle also said he 'was not aware of performance problems with respect to several of the U.S. attorneys' when he called to fire them, according to Schumer."

user-pic

30 minutes till Gonzo is in the hotseat. Can't wait (rubbing hands greedily).

user-pic

Civil rights prosecutions seems to be a common thread in these firings. Ironic that a conspiracy to deny people voting rights is being orchestrated out of the Department of Justice. And I use the word "conspiracy" in the legally prosecutable way.

user-pic

One other follow up.

On the lawsuit that Graves didn't want to file, but Schlozman did eventually get filed -- in April 2007, a federal judge dismissed the case.

user-pic

There is no need to prepare to tell the truth. We saw what happened when Gonzales had a month to prepare his truth. If Schlozman doesn't want to testify next week, subpoena his ass for tomorrow. He can come back later with more information if that turns out to be necessary.

user-pic

There is no need to prepare to tell the truth. We saw what happened when Gonzales had a month to prepare his truth. If Schlozman doesn't want to testify next week, subpoena his ass for tomorrow. He can come back later with more information if that turns out to be necessary.
Posted by: fuzz
Amen! Enough of going along with the Republican delays. That is their strategy. Delay, delay, delay in the hopes that the Dems won't take a look at all their other crimes. At this point the Dems have to be aware of this gameplan- so stop playing along with it!

user-pic

Question for Gonzales today:

The firing of Missouri U.S. Attorney Todd Graves within days after the passage of the Patriot Act, which included a provision that allowed the President to appoint U.S. Attorney without congressional approval. Mr. Graves was immediately replaced by Barry Schlozman, the first U.S. Attorney to be appointed under the new provision. The close timing of these events seem to be more than just coincidental.

Mr. Gonzales, what do you know about the circumstances surrounding the insertion of that special provision into the Patriot Act under the name of Senator Arlen Specter? Who was the source of the provision that worked it's way into the Senate's bill?

user-pic

Let's get it started! Let's get it started in here! It'd be nice if some folks showed up wearing orange jumpsuits.

user-pic

Gonzales is looking shakey- very uncertain of himself. I think he realizes he is in deep shit after the reports released last night about a ninth attorney- can you say "perjurer". So long Gonzo!

user-pic

Patience please, let's take the time necessary to follow the thread of evil that this administration has woven through "our" government.

I was 10 years old in 1954 when the Army-McCarthy Hearings were broadcast gavel to gavel by ABC.

http://www.museum.tv/archives/etv/A/htmlA/army-mccarthy/army-mccarthy.htm

I'll be enjoying today's history lesson also, and so will the rest of the world.

The credibility of the U.S. is at stake. If we can't cure this infection that the Bush administration has brought to our former way of life, others will join with our current "enemies" to stop the infection before it spreads.

user-pic

Recall how Rove smugly stated that he "had the math." The math included the Missouri Senate seat in 2006 (read the antics of goon Schlozman). But, unlike Florida in '00 and Ohio in '04, things didn't work as planned. Oops!

user-pic

if some of the Rove appointed prosecutors who went after exaggerated or bogus Dem voter fraud cases trying to divert attention from real GOP election fraud in time for the elections it would be a relatively useless move unless Rove could get a lot of PR points.

since Rove's most unnacountable propaganda medium is talk radio it may be of interest to investigators to interview talk radio hosts who were given Dem voter fraud talking points before the elections to find patterns in terms of timing and sources.

as was the case in Florida and then somewhat in NM for the Wilson/Madrid recount, the GOP makes sure to get the public riled to intimidate election workers. there is no better medium for doing that than talk radio. in NM 770 KKOB did the job, but the Dems seemed to be ready this time.

and in this caase it may have backfired with the locall KKOB dittoheads putting pressure on Domenici to make a big boo boo.

user-pic

Ugh...did you see this paragraph from Eric Lipton's story in the Times today? I nearly spit my cereal at the paper.

"The administration saw such lawsuits as a way to combat voter fraud. But Democrats have said the lawsuits were politically motivated because poor and elderly voters were more likely to be taken off registration rolls."

Oh, did the administration really see them as a way to combat voter fraud? Yes, that's what they say, but isn't the truth of that statement rather highly contested, isn't that, in fact, the heart of this whole fucking matter? To report that as if it were a fact (particularly juxtaposed against the "Democrats say" construction of the following sentence) just floors me.

user-pic

Here's the thing... The January "firing" does not fit the Rove timeline for influencing the election outcome so Grave's conjecture that this was about a clash over prosectution of votre fraud. No, this is more likely about a pending corruption case in which Jeb Bush sits on the board of the defense. When will the main stream media focus in on the Grave's caseload and corruption prosecutions - the voter purge makes no sense in this timeline.

user-pic

Shame on Specter for "letting his aids" modify the law without his oversight.

And shame on the democrats for not reading what they were voting for/against. Any casual reading of the infamous blurb (by anyone) would have set off alarm bells.

user-pic

psyopswatcher has revealed the real story, and if someone read their e-mails, they would have known about the 10 (ten) purged attorney's on April 23, 2007.

See pressrelease365.com May 10, 2007 where they cover the story from 4/9/07 about Medical Supply Chain (in a huge lawsuit) receiving in discovery documents,

"The e-mail dated January 9th, 2006 from Kyle Sampson, chief of staff for Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, to Harriet Miers and William Kelley at the White House, shows the ten U.S. Attorneys that were first selected to voluntarily resign or face termination. Attorneys that resigned were redacted. Todd P. Graves of Missouri resigned March 24, 2006."

user-pic

The voter registration purge in the case of Graves is a RED HERRING. The real story is which public-corruption cases were dropped when Graves was replaced by Shlozman, who had never prosecuted a case before.

user-pic

Bush's brother is on the board that is being investigated in Texas via Missouri!!!!!!!!!!!!!

user-pic

Has no one yet connected the dots? The Rovian aide who replaced Cummins in AR has as expertise "oppo". Hillary is running for president. Recall all the false scandals which originated in AR, and which were slung at Clinton? And Ted Olson being head of the "AR Project"? And that Olson is "Federalist Society"?

It's part of the setup for '08: expect Hillary to be the lead candidate on the Democratic side, and endeavor to destroy her, exactly as they -- Cummins' replacement -- targetted both Gore and Kerry.

I don't know where these people are from (Rove, et al.), but they are clearly not Americans.

user-pic

What has been overlooked was the purging of career DOJ attorneys at the same time (Dec 06)such as AUSA Mike Jones, head of the Springfield MO office. No doubt Schlozman was directly responsible.

Another spin on the Graves matter is that Mr. Cummins was investigating the patronage received by Graves' family of lucrative Motor vehicle fee offices in Missouri from Missouri's joke governor, Matt Blunt. I believe three of these cash cows went to Grave family members, including his wife. Blunt's campaign hired counsel to attempt to deflect this investigation, which disappeared when Mr. Cummins was fired.

user-pic

bziu iaztmpdus heajskwx lzdabg juki riube uvzlwhopc

user-pic

bziu iaztmpdus heajskwx lzdabg juki riube uvzlwhopc

user-pic

MSN I NIIPET
MSN

user-pic

MSN I NIIPET
MSN

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address