TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Govt's Kooky Cult Terrorism Case Goes Bust

The Miami "Seas of David" terror bust was such an important blow in the War on Terror that Attorney General Alberto Gonzales himself gave a press conference in July of 2006. Federal agents had stopped a plot to blow up the Sears Tower, he said. The group had planned to "accomplish attacks against America," the FBI's deputy director said at Gonzales side. "We pre-empted their plot."

But, as we wrote at the time, "the more we learn, the less this crew looks like they could have toppled a tree house, let alone the Sears Tower." The clique, adherents of a sect "that mixes Islam, Buddhism, Christianity, Freemasonry, Gnosticism and Taoism," met in a windowless warehouse they called the "Temple." The leader of the group, Narseal Batiste, was described as a "'Moses-like figure' who would roam the streets in a cape or bathrobe, toting a crooked wooden cane and looking for young men to join his group." And when the group met in their Temple, the men "took turns standing guard outside the door, dressed up in makeshift military uniforms and combat boots. Sometimes they covered their faces with ski masks." Nobody ever charged them with being subtle.

And it was unclear whether the group really had any plans themselves, or whether they got all their ideas from the FBI informant. When the FBI raided the Temple, FBI agents found only one knife and a blackjack. The group trained by shooting paintball guns in the woods.

Sure enough, the government's case ended today with one exoneration and six mistrials. "The government wants to try them again next year," the BBC reports.


37 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

We must try them again

Because if we even think they are a danger

We cannot take taht chance

We need to protect our liberty

user-pic

I agree

TRY and TRY again untill you succeed

Thats what our parents use to tell us

God, thats what make this country great

user-pic

This abusive litigation can backfire against the US government: In the form of lower public confidence in the US system of justice.

Don't miss the key issue: These are American citizens under surveillance, and being harassed for being unusual. Despite a mistrial, the US govt wants another trial. Huh? That's not a speedy trial, but punishment by judicial abuse. Does not have the appearance of justice, but punishment through trial.

A. Warrants

How much information were JTTF-DHS gathering without getting the required warrants and judicial oversight; Where else is this kind of surveillance happening?

B. First to cry wolf: Scapegoating

Why is it so easy to get false information into the system, but so difficult to ensure that absurd information is not vetted?

Who within the DHS "mandatory reporting" system has an incentive to provide false information to investigators to distract attention from the DHS-related problems (security violations, illegal disclosures of secure information)?

C. Accused punished without trial:

- How many other Americans -- on accusation alone for opposing the US president's illegal activity -- are under similar surveillance?
- How many Americans -- that are similar to this group -- are under surveillance, but really not a real threat to anyone?
- How many Americans have been threatened, "Unless you cooperate with our non-sense investigation, we're going to prosecute you?"

user-pic

The Gang That Couldn't Shoot Straight prosecuted the Gang That Couldn't Shoot Straight. No verdict, just what this case called for. That's over. Let's move along now, the real adults have work to do...

user-pic

"We must try them again

Because if we even think they are a danger

We cannot take taht chance

We need to protect our liberty"

That's right what the fuck does actually being guilty of committing some crime have to do with it.

user-pic

- How many other Americans -- on accusation alone for opposing the US president's illegal activity -- are under similar surveillance?
- How many Americans -- that are similar to this group -- are under surveillance, but really not a real threat to anyone?
- How many Americans have been threatened, "Unless you cooperate with our non-sense investigation, we're going to prosecute you?"

Use as many examples as you want, but it boils down to the War On Terrorism being one huge false positive.

jswift: don't feed the trolls.

user-pic

I knew there was something fishy about that whole case. That whole thing just reeked of racism.

"Oh, look. Let's investigate these kooky-looking Haitian spooks who invented their own religion and meet together and have Voodoo conclaves in an abandoned warehouse. Surely they must have ties to Al-Qaeda...."

user-pic

Tyrone: It's not racism, it's hysteria.

user-pic

[ EH wrote on December 13, 2007 7:12 PM ]

"Use as many examples as you want, but it boils down to the War On Terrorism being one huge false positive."

A. Budge Authority Based on Fraud

How much money has been spent chasing ghosts?

B. Pretextual Stops

How many in JTTF/Law enforcement -- looking for excuses to abuse power -- are citing "terrorism" to get information and interrogate US citizens knowing full well they do not have the required informatoin to get a warrant or subpoena?

user-pic

[ EH wrote on December 13, 2007 7:44 PM ]

Congress is part of the hysterial, not the moderated oversight expected of informed leaders in a Republic.

Who is watching the watchers?

user-pic

I mean, I know they weren't really helping their own cause by running around in military camo, wearing ski-masks, and having paintball matches all of the time, but seriously, the feds actually thought these guys were capable of carrying out a major terrorist operation on US soil??

I guess Gonzo must have thought they had averted another David Koresh/Branch Davidian/Waco catastrophe at the time. Sheesh. What kind of clowns do they have running DOJ right now??

user-pic

They were far from being fundamentalists!

They were into all kinds of stuff.

Conclusion: they were political prisoners.

user-pic

I think it is racism: they would never have
picked a bunch of wacky white guys for this ; because their base wouldnt have been frightened enough by white guys,

user-pic

WATERBOARD THEM TILL THEY CONFESS!

user-pic

I hate to say it, but I think ma miller is right.

Could Jose Padilla, a NATIVE BORN US CITIZEN, have been held for 5 years w/o being charged if he was white? I have a real hard time imagining that they could get away with effectively stripping him of his citizenship if his name and face matched what passes for "real American" in the eyes of many.

user-pic

Isn't trying them again double jeopardy?
This was banner headline on Fox news when the story broke. It gave the Bushies reason to believe they were actually protecting us from terrorists, while they ignored power plants and ports. These guys couldn't blow up a balloon.

user-pic

Isn't trying them again double jeopardy?
This was banner headline on Fox news when the story broke. It gave the Bushies reason to believe they were actually protecting us from terrorists, while they ignored power plants and ports. These guys couldn't blow up a balloon.

user-pic

The results of their trial are a pretty clear sign of their guilt. This is an obvious case of using innocent people to beat the rap. A very clever ruse indeed - not many terrorist cells have the resources or talent to pull this off. But our DOJ has seen this before and knows how to deal with it. That's why the USA is numero uno.

user-pic

This prosecution wasted a lot of time and money for nothing. The US Attorneys normally decline anything that isn't guaranteed to win in court, passing up many cases with strong evidence. This is what happens when politics drives the prosecution rather than the merits of the case. They are so desperate to get some good press in the "war on terror" that they will grasp at straws to prosecute anyone claiming to have Al Qaida links.

One day soon I'll start selling my patented 12 Step program to catch more terrorists and impress hot women. BUT WAIT, THAT'S NOT ALL! You'll also get my free guide to restaurants offering federal agent discounts, ABSOLUTELY FREE. Operators will be standing by to take your orders for this limited-time offer.

user-pic

Why are americans such chickenshits. 'Land of the brave' indeed, I sure have not seen much bravery from my neighbor to the south for as long as I can remember.

user-pic

I'm reading all this and thinking, for all the BS and the changing narrative, all I see is these billboards in the highways that say "REPORT SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITY" and these are HUGE expensive signs, and I wonder isn't it suspicious that somebody came up with this idea and hasn't been prosecuted for waste when the world has millions of cell phones and dedicated 911 service?

I mean honestly folks.. stop and think of the changing narrative, the torture, the non-existent WMD, the prosecution record of our current GITMO detainees, our broken borders, and some A-hole came up with the idea to build those stupid ass signs...

Smells like PSOPS to me...

I mean honestly folks.. whad-da-fukk? Have you seen these signs?

TPM oughta get an insight into who got the contract for that gig and putting out US flags on the over-passes, thats the question I want asked, "was any taxpayer money spent on draping flags off of over-passes along side the large ugly call this number instead of 911 signs where so much money was pissed away."

Certainly no stranger than these muts who:

"mix Islam, Buddhism, Christianity, Freemasonry, Gnosticism and Taoism"

Hey I got an idea, lets reinvent the 911 emergency concept and build signs all accross the country to do so.....

Those signs should be auctioned off or rented to the private sector and whoever's idea it was to spend money this way be put in jail.

user-pic

mamiller is correct - racism. I used to live in Miami. Want to scare the bejeebus out of everyone in S. FL? Just say 'Liberty City', then throw in a Haitian name. Try to accuse a Cuban in Miami of terrorism...whoa Elian Gonzales all over again!

user-pic

Time for a circular firing squad. the case was laughable, DOJ is a bigger joke than a car full of clowns. Bush can look at the destruction of Justice as a crowning achievement.

user-pic

Yeh we probably should ignore nut case extremists. It's way better to have them back in the neighborhood where they can continue being the productive citizens that they were.

There's no chance that someone with a little more brains or charisma could come along and actually bring their plans to fruition. We would never have to worry about Jerk*ffs complaining how the Fed's. "Had an intelligence failure" or "failed to connect the dots" would we? No way Jose.

There also no chance that these dopes would decide that a low tech plan or a copycat crime like shooting up a mall full of Christians might not be a easier alternative is there. Nah. Not a chance.

Paul Harvey is a tool.

user-pic

moondancer: I love your posts!

Yes, this case is a case of the govt looking in a mirror... and seeing itself in these kooks!

user-pic

Oopsie! Another failed prosecution in our war on terror. So what happened? Did the DOJ forget the rules of evidence and decided to proceed with the trial anyway hoping against hope that 12 jurors would be duped into handing out guilty verdicts?

http://13martyrs.blogspot.com/

user-pic

"Why are americans such chickenshits. 'Land of the brave' indeed, I sure have not seen much bravery from my neighbor to the south for as long as I can remember."

I'm with you! The Republican bedwetters have managed to terrify simple-minded Americans (of which there are many). A large segment of the public is acting like schoolgirls at a church picnic running screaming from the thunder.

I am embarrassed and ashamed, as I have been for the last 7 years. When will this nightmare end?

user-pic

hey hosers:

thats "land of the free" and "home of the brave"

but other than that i got no problems with your complaints

user-pic

Is anybody really surprised by this? Nope. The one thing that is functioning is the american jury system. Thank God. Where is gonzo for the press conference announcing this result? Or how about a king press conference? It's that global war on poor people, I mean terrorists right.

user-pic

This is the whole reason why those 'terrorists' at Guantanimo have been persecuted rather than prosecuted. Nobody bothered to gather any creditable evidence against them. They were just rounded up, declared to be 'terrorists' and shipped to Guantanimo, or to other 'secret' prisons.
The torture they experience is an attempt to gain 'evidence' to cover up this fact. This is also why the Military Commissions Act was necessary - to get coerced testimony into the record as fact and to convict people based on whatever they said to stop the torture.

user-pic

Michael A wrote on December 14, 2007 8:48 AM: "The one thing that is functioning is the american jury system."

Mike: It is? Why do you think the Military Commissions Act was passed. Under that Act, there is a panel of military judges serving as both judge and jury. The accused doesn't even have the right to face their accusers and call them liars, or to review any of the evidence against them. That would violate National Security.

user-pic

It appears that the war on terror is an absolute fraud. There has not been a single prosecution that I can recall where any of these terror plots were more than a bunch of stoner idiots snagged into plans by informants. Fort Dix? The Kennedy Oil Terminals? Aqua Teen Hunger Force?

And yet, the US Attorneys involved in prosecuting the cases decide to announce them on a megaphone to the nation before objectively analyzing any of them. I guess in the Bushisized DOJ prosecuting bogus cases and scaring the public unnecessarily is par for the course.

user-pic

To Captain America:

Just because someone may come along later and give these guys a real crime to commit doesn't mean the government gets to entrap them. Law enforcement can't say, "Hey these guys look like they might commit a crime. Let's suggest one to them!"

user-pic

There are no "organized terrorist" (Islam/Muslim religious cults) out to "get you", there are no plots to kill every man woman or child in the U.S...the only plot that is being perpetuated on you is a political plot from your own government, to turn this country into Nazi Germany, the U.S.S.R and Saudi Arabia all rolled into one...a military junta, a dictatorship, a fascist state, a theocracy, or a plutocracy..take your pick..it will be a combination, whichever one will give a despot the most control over the people and the most direct way to steal from the treasury (your tax dollars) at any time the dictator, despot or Commander in Chief (and his minions) feel like it

user-pic

To the ham-handed agent-provocateur:

"Yeah, get us the guns and the money and the boots. Sure, we'll blow up the Sears Tower - whatever. Can you get us cars? Don't forget the money. When's the money coming?"

That's what passes for the War on Terror in the Bush regime. And to think it's only cost us two trillion dollars, thousands of lives and our constitutional rights.

user-pic

Hey, you go into a mid-term election with the terrorist plots you have, not the terrorist plots you wish you had.

user-pic

"Mike: It is? Why do you think the Military Commissions Act was passed. Under that Act, there is a panel of military judges serving as both judge and jury. The accused doesn't even have the right to face their accusers and call them liars, or to review any of the evidence against them. That would violate National Security." Posted by Johann.

Actually, it gets even better than that; with the military commissions you don't even get to know what you're charged with. You're guilty because we say you are.

You don't have to be a blind conservative not to see it, just an ignorant one to deny it.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address