TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

White House Wags Finger at Plagiarizing Aide

From Justin over at ABC:

"We were just made aware about Tim's column and his actions this morning," said White House spokeswoman Emily Lawrimore. "Obviously this is not acceptable." Lawrimore would not comment on whether the president would ask Goeglein to resign, saying the White House was still "looking into the details."

As we noted in an update below, commenters over at blogger Nancy Nall's site have been dredging up example after example of Goeglein's instances of plagiarism. Judging by a selection of his columns, Goeglein's trouble stems from his preeningly erudite writing style, a style he was evidently unable to sustain on his own.


21 Comments

| Leave a comment

Umm. I don't know about you.. but that pic is weird.... look at his flushed cheeks, the redness in the eyes... the guys hammered!

Ummm.... redness in the cheeks...bloodshoot eyes.
Methinks the guy was hammered in this pic.

He delivered a touching tribute to Jerry Falwell, who is now dancing with God.

Resign? Please. Head Bush speechwriter.

Here's a visual showing how he changed the words.

No Hart Feelings:

"I told him I was flattered he'd used it. It doesn't damage him in my estimation at all. I'm glad he spread the word."

Even The Onion saw this coming.

Look at the other dirty deeds of Jason Blair, per The Onion.

Ask him to resign for plagarism? Honesty and originality have never been present in this White House so what's there to be accountable for? This is just a very small drop in a rainstorm.

Here's an interesting study on plagiarism:

"While this certainly does not excuse academic misconduct by university officials, my research indicates that, at least at SIU, administrators are too far removed from the students to influence their behavior." From ( H/t )

If not inspired by the Oval Office, he must be punished by DoJ.

You were looking for an a href="http://www.stlyrics.com/songs/t/tomlehrer3903/lobachevsky185511.html">iPod download as background music for this story? h/t

The count is up to twenty on the number of plagiarized columns.

"Mr. Goeglein usually attends a White House meeting around 8:30 a.m. each weekday with Mr. Rove and eight other officials to settle on the administration's message for the day" ( From/a> )

Where's the original work Goeglein used to develop the "message for the day": Which contractors were sending this into the White House email system?

Contracts to Analyze NSA Media Messaging How much of the "message of the day" is related to NSA-related media messaging analysis, forwarded to the White House?; How do the illegal FISA warrants fit into the media message analysis Goeglein was involved in publishing?

Telecom Immunity Scare Tactis How much of the White House "message of the day" on the NSA telecoms was funneled from the telecoms through Goeglein into the White House press office?

War Crimes What involvement did Goeglein with the "message of the day" on FISA violations, prisoner abuse, illegal warfare, war crimes?

TPMM and US Atty Firings Subpoenas How does this information transfer between the public affairs office where Goeglein worked fit int with the US Atty firings; and the documented coordination between DoJ Staff and the political, legal, and public affairs offices?

Free trips:

Tim Goeglein (liaison to conservative groups) took $30,000 in trips. Among the countries visited: Norway, Latvia, Sweden, Australia.
Who picked up the tab? Dozens of conservative and pro-business groups including the American Enterprise Institute, Southern Baptist Convention, Focus on the Family, the Federalist Society and the National Association of Manufacturers.

The link between the White House, Federalist Society, and the NSA telecoms has been established; and is positively linked to the WH Political office. The House Judiciary Committee, because of the alleged copyright issue on Goeglein's computer, can now ask questions about the seized computer:

- FISA violations When did the Federalist Society coordinate with the telecoms and Goeglein on issues of NSA immunity; how were these coordinating memos archived on Goeglein's computer ; what connection does Goeglein have with the DoD contractors assigned to violate the FISA requirements?

- Geneva What role did the Federalist Society play in issuing public messages through Goeglein to mislead Congress on issues of Geneva, war crimes, and legal counsel attachment to those frivolous legal arguments; when did Goeglein save these memos?

- JAGs To what extent was the Federalist Society using Goeglein to issue statements designed to downplay the Geneva concerns the JAGs raised on issues of prisoner abuse, war crimes, and illegal violations of the Geneva Conventions; what involvement did Goeglein have with the WH e-mail contractors?

- Smith Act How many formerly assigned White House counsel linked with the Federalist Society had an interest in rewarding Goeglein for issuing unattributed media messages designed to mislead the public on issues of war crimes, prisoner abuse, NSA illegal activity, FISA violations;

- To what extent were media messages placed in Iraq, and forwarded through the White House/Goeglein with the intent to mislead the Congress on issues of WMD, Iraq insurgency, and issues warranting Congressional oversight?

Guidance reltes to this documentation Trip records:

- These are funds' transfers which can be traced to their sources.
- The check routing numbers can be compared to the NSA/telecom contracts of contractors working with the WH email system
- Also are the travel/hotel records: Phone calls made, services used

See pages
1. 2 of 46:
2. 8 of 46:
3. 11 of 46:
4. 14 of 46:
5. 16 of 46: National Review
6. 20 of 26:
7. 29 of 46:
8. 31 of 46: Federalist Society
9. 32 of 46: Aspen Institute, Berlin
10. 33 of 46:
11. 37 of 46:
12. 39 of 46: Movieguide, Los Angeles
13. 45 of 46:

FOIAs in re Goeglein. There are other reports which have his name on it, and can be requested.

Here is the guidance which WH Counsel will have to respond within 30 days:

(5) Public availability of reports.

Except as provided in paragraph (a)(6) of this section, the Director of OGE shall make any report filed pursuant to this section available for public inspection and copying within 30 days after the applicable due date or within 30 days after the date OGE actually receives the report, whichever is later.

Putting aside Goeglein's particular travel, we can broadly review all the travel information for all the WH personnel.

§ 304–1.5 Conflict-of-interest analysis.
(a) Payment from a non-Federal source shall not be accepted if the authorized agency official determines that acceptance under the circumstances would cause a reasonable person with knowledge of all the facts relevant to a particular case to question the integrity of agency programs or operations. From

This doesn't mean a "person inside WH counsel's office," but the opposite: Somemone who is reasonabe, and knows about:

- US Atty firings
- Political office involvement with public affairs on US Atty, Miers, and Bolten issues
- NSA telecoms
- FISA violations
- Prisoner abuse, Geneva violations, war crimes

Questions:

- Would someone with all the facts on the table, when reviewing all the travel reimbursements, see there was a conflict in re telecoms, war crimes, prisoner abuse, and frivolous legal arguments by counsel in blocking oversight?

- Who would do a "reasonable review of the facts" if the WH personnel have their head in the sand?

Here's a key factor in analyzing the funds transfer. Relies on other issues: "Any matter pending".

"(4) The nature and sensitivity of any matter pending at the agency affecting the interests of the non-Federal source;

- Which of the NSA telecoms have paid WH personnel for trips
- What's the relationship between the "request for immunity"; and media messages Goeglein and others, through the public affairs office, have coordinated/issued through the White House?

Take a look at Goeglein's connections with this media camapaign.

- How were the media messages coordinated with the White House, legal counsel, and outside counsel working with AT&T, NSA, and the telecoms?

- What was Goeglein's role in coordinating messages between the White House, AT&T, NSA, and outside counsel on media messages related to the NSA telecom issues before Congress?

- When did Goeglein get involved with the statements provided to Congress about the "big scary events" that would happen unless the telecoms were given immunity?

Those who support the NSA's illegal activity appear to have an intereset in discrediting opponents of the White House's "moral" agena. Look who was discrediting attacks on the White house, while spewing forth non-sense about the NSA. Goeglein's conduct means the attack on Kuo are meaningless From:

Kuo, by the way, has been embraced by the media, welcomed everywhere from 60 Minutes to the Colbert Report. His tale of White House hypocrisy in dealing with religious conservatives is bogus. We know this from the number of religious conservatives in high positions at the White House: Bush himself, Mike Gerson, Karen Hughes, Peter Wehner, Tim Goeglein, and that's just for starters. Colbert asked Kuo why he wrote the book.

After today, citing Goeglein can backfire. These claims have been discredited:

"Today, Democrats would deny the president the tools. They would weaken, if not eliminate, the Patriot Act. They would halt the tough but entirely legal interrogations of terrorist leaders that have proved so successful in uncovering and thwarting plots to strike America a second time and perhaps a third or a fourth. They would constrain the National Security Agency from eavesdropping on terrorist phone calls to and from America."

Again, those who want to discredit attacks on the NSA's illegal activity have a strange fascination with relying on Goeglein for verbal armor.

The author of the piece was Fred Barnes. Look at the common links between him and Goeglein.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address