« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

New Well-Connected Conservative Group Runs Pro-Coleman Ad

There are already indications that the 2008 election will be remarkable for the number of outside groups weighing in with major ad buys supporting or attacking candidates. The latest: a group called the American Future Fund that's hit Minnesota with a TV ad singing the praises of Sen. Norm Coleman (R-MN), who's locked in an already tight reelection battle with Al Franken.

You can see the ad, which began running March 19th and will last for approximately three weeks, below. With the feel-good synthesized music characteristic of positive ads playing soothingly in the background, it lauds Coleman's legislative accomplishments ("Coleman has worked with Republicans and Democrats to make college more affordable" etc.), adds, "An independent voice for Minnesota: Norm Coleman," and ends by urging viewers to call Coleman and "thank him." The ad buy cost "well into six figures," according to Larry McCarthy, the media consultant who produced it.

Because the group has established itself as a non-profit -- the popular choice this election for outside groups wanting to spend money without restraint while disclosing little to nothing about their activities -- details on the new group are sketchy.

The Rothenberg Political Report reported last month that a number of notable conservatives are associated with the group (no one seems to head the group, exactly, as you'll see below). McCarthy, the media consultant, runs a major firm that also recently produced ads attacking House Democrats run by another outside group called Defense of Democracies.

Also associated with the group, Rothenberg reported, are "veteran GOP legal advisor Ben Ginsberg," former counsel to the Bush-Cheney campaign among other spots, and "former Republican Governors Association (RGA) executive director Ed Tobin."

My call requesting more information about the group was referred to Dave Kochel, a former Iowa Republican Party director, who told me that he was the spokesperson for the Iowa Future Fund, a group that has been running negative ads against Gov. Chet Culver (D), but that he was also involved with the American Future Fund "in a limited capacity." When I asked him who was running the group, he confirmed Rothenberg's reporting that Ginsberg and McCarthy were "involved," but said that neither of them was in charge. Those are "the only people who have been identified with the group," he said.

When I asked if the group would get involved in other races, he responded that it was "very possible," but "I don't think we're going to air our strategy in public.... We'll make decisions as we go along where we can be most effective and most helpful."


Comments (53)

avatar

Didn't a pro-Hillary group get into trouble for running an ad just like this? I thought they were not allowed to implicitly endorse a candidate.

avatar

Does Norm really think he can win against the funny?

Dunno. Perhaps as a "thank you" ad, it doesn't technically endorse Coleman over Franken.

-AF

Andrew Sullivan Is A Fraud

There are already indications that the 2008 election will be remarkable for the number of outside groups weighing in with major ad buys supporting or attacking candidates

Hm, but since as your own reporting notes this appears to be run by Republican consultants and operatives, is this really most accurately described as an example of an "outside group"? It seems like an "outside group" would be someone more like the American Federation of Teachers.

I don't care for Franken.

Franken is running to take back the seat of Sen. Paul Wellstone, the second Dem senator/candidate to die in a plane crash in consecutive elections (the first being Mel Carnahan, whose wife went on to beat Incumbent Republican Senator John Ashcroft in Missouri, whereby after the later Wellstone crash there was no widow survivor to run against the republican candidate as she was killed in the crash too).

Franken is pretty progressive, although I'm not sure yet if he will adequately fill Wellstone's shoes. I suspect he will do a fine job, and the more progressive Senators the better in my opinion.

Policy-wise, I'm sure he's fine. Just as a person, I've always found him more annoying than anything else. That's all I meant.

avatar

OK, so what?

haha, just posting an opinion on a comment board is all...

There has to be enough dirt to bury Norman. He's too much of a skirt-chaser to have remained out of sight on that one.

And before anyone says "Let's keep the tone up..." I say this: After the campaign he ran before and after Paul Wellstone died, I want him personally destroyed, mulling Third World exile.

avatar

Ginsberg: Atty for CREA's Frederici?

Amen.

compared to coleman? come on.

avatar

Wasn't Ginsberg the lawyer for the Swift-boater's?

Norms a tool and a clown.

Go Al, we need another good progressive in Paul's seat.

avatar

Coleman is also the person who tried to get George Galloway into legal trouble by calling him to the Senate to answer charges of corruption. Watch the video of the hearing:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3VHAco8y18

Notice what a slimy, sneaky, and utterly bullshit Coleman's charge is.

Here's yet another of these "nonprofit" groups, with its opaque operation and a mission that is openly politically partisan. The definition of what and what cannot be established as a nonprofit entity must be cleaned up and tightened.

I know the list of things to fix is very, very long, but it might behoove the Congress to bump this one to the top of the list, before the proliferation of these groups gets out of hand. In case they hadn't heard, there's a big election coming up.

Good production values + a credulous public = Republican winners.

That's too dangerous to keep allowing.

Well, well, well. I traced American Future Fund to our old friends at Holtzmann Vogel. The Iowa registration lists the incorporator as Jessica Young at 98 Alexandria Pike, Ste 53, Warrenton, VA which is the Holtzmann Vogel address.

Alex N. Vogel, of course, is a very well-known Republican operative last written about here in connection with the American Center For Voting Rights and the Free Enterprise Coalition. Mark "Thor" Hearne was one of Vogel's associates at the ACVR.

Jill Holtzman Vogel, another Republican operative and Alex Vogel's wife, won a VA state senate seat last year. 25% of the $1.7 million raised by Holtzman Vogel came from businessman, David Rensin.

The Vogels are very good at raising money from secret sources.



The American Future Fund and the Iowa Future Fund are both linked to Holtzman Vogel.

The incorporator for the non-profit corporations is Jessica Young, at the Warrenton VA address listed above. The corporations were registered on August 7, 2007 and have consecutive i.d. numbers.

An Eric Peterson filed a fictitious name resolution on 2/7/08 for the Iowa Future Fund to do business as IFF. Peterson listed himself as president, director and secretary.

Eric Peterson might be Eric Peterson, business manager of Summit Farms in Iowa. Peterson contributed $2k to Guiliani's campaign and as did other Summit Farms employees.

Summit Farms is owned by Bruce Rastetter, a wealthy businessman who is now heavy into building ethanol plants. Rastetter is a big donor to the Republican Party and has contributed several thousand dollars to Norm Coleman. He too contributed $2k to Guiliani.

Norm Coleman is co-chairman of the Senate Biofuels Caucus and has pushed legislation supporting the ethanol industry.

As an aside, neither American Future Fund nor Iowa Future Fund appears to be registered with the IRS as a non-profit.

JMM should be paying you to do this, Mrs P. -- I got the two filings before reading the comments, and found yours before I was going to post. Of course, I didn't have the Holtzman Vogel stuff quite yet, though I was knocking on the door.

What's annoying is that the Iowa corporations search won't list addresses, and is only presenting one page of the two pages filed, perhaps just a cover sheet but it's not there. They may contain mailing addresses for Peterson, too, which are offered as a hyperlink on the results page but contain no information in this case. A telephone query to the IA Secretary of State's office during normal business hours is in order.

I would not be at all surprised if Bruce Rastetter put money into American Future Fund and Iowa Future Fund. He is politically ambitious and considered running against Senator Tom Harkin this year.

On the other hand, Rastetter is in the ethanol industry and the corn industry is heavily subsidized by the federal government to the tune of something like $9 billion. Rastetter might not want the Dems to know the extent of his anti-Democratic funding.

This, of course, is just a guess on my part. But if Eric Peterson, Summit Farms business manager, is Iowa Future Fund president, then it is a darned good guess.


You nailed it, Mrs P. Pretty good guess, indeed.

Should have noted, too, that while Rastetter and Schlieman donated to Peterson (both on 10/24/2007), Rastetter, Schlieman, and Peterson all gave $2000 to Giuliani.

Got the amounts wrong, but 10/24/2007 seems to be an auspicious date here.

Coincidence or not? Justin Peterson of DCI Group, whose stomping grounds were Nebraska and Iowa, also gave $1000 to Coleman on 10/24/2007. DCI, of course, has huge Iowa and Minnesota connections (Feather Larson & Synhorst, what an axis).

A lot of Akin Gump Strauss and Covington & Burling contributions landed in Coleman's coffers on that day, too.

Can't sleep yet...

Should I mention that Kochel was a DCI VP? Remember, DCI ran their own candidate for Congress in Iowa in 2006. Brian Kennedy, DCI lobbyist, ran in IA-1 and came in third in the GOP primary after raising $400,000, a huge sum for a first-timer candidate in a primary election.

avatar

Other Iowans who donated to Norm Coleman on 10/24/2007: Brent Rastettler (Bruce's son), Alan Rosendahl (ISB/Banker), Robin Sampson (Hawkeye Renewables), Todd Steen (Hawkeye/Accountant)....

That's just people whose surnames begin with R and S... haven't searched the rest of the filings yet.

Meet Eric Peterson.

Hi Wander!

Great to see you here. I downloaded all three filings in tif format and the two regs have two pages. Nothing worthwhile on them though. The fictitious name resolution was only one page. I am disappointed that Iowa requires so little info from a non-profit.

Thanks for the link to Eric Peterson. I sent him an email and asked him if he is the president of Iowa Future Fund. Who knows, maybe he will answer me.

Interesting that Peterson, a year out of college, contributed $2k to Rudy, no?

As an aside, I have a feeling these 504(c)s are going to be the bane of the 2008 election. No one knows where the money is coming from and the FEC is a disaster. Not that the FEc ever seems to do much until after an election.

Some of Rastetter's contributions to Coleman and others in 2005-6-7 associate him with Heartland Pork, of which he was CEO, but it was dissolved by shareholders on 3/25/2004. He was knowingly misreporting his employment information on his campaign contributions.

He does list Hawkeye Renewables on one of his donations, one of those ethanol plants you refer to, which is also listed on its initial filing as Iowa Falls Ethanol Plant, LLC. There is also Hawkeye Energy Holdings/Hawkeye Holdings.

And is J.D. Schlieman, Rastetter's partner in many operations, involved in American Future Fund, as well? He has also contributed to Norm Coleman's 2008 campaign.

I have to cut this short for tonight but from what I can gather, Rastetter sold Heartland Pork in 2004 but I'm not sure how much money he made. The company apparently was losing money.

Then Rastetter goes into the ethanol industry which is now overbuilt. His company, Hawkeye Renewables, was supposed to go public and filed an S-1 with the SEC but the offering was aborted.

I'll see what I can dig up in the morning.

Hi back at ya!

Hopefully the Muck gang will do something with your digging... ;-) and we'll both have more to work with in the morning, as I'm calling it a night too.

Okay, one more before the night's over... Kent Krause of Iowa Falls, a pork farmer, is involved with Rastetter in Iowa Winds, LLC, a wind energy company of all things, and he also donated to Coleman on 10/24/2007.

Still have to search FEC donation reports for Coleman, L-O and then U-Z. First part of the alphabet is done.

I searched L-O and U-Z. Another possibility is Roger Underwood of Becker Underwood who contributed $1k to Coleman on 10/24/07. Underwood has made $52k in political contributions since 2000, almost all of which went to Republicans.

Ken Mehlman was one of the Akin Gump donors on 10/24/07. I noticed, too, that Ken's brother, Bruce Mehlman of Mehlman, Vogel, Castagnetti contributed in April 2007. The Vogel in MVC is Alex N. Vogel, also of Holtzman Vogel.

MVC was listed as the executive director of American Center For Voting Rights in the 2005 990 and was paid $75k. Holtzman Vogel was also paid by American Center For Voting Rights (501(c)(3)) and American Center For Voting Rights Fund (501(c)(4)).

Thanks!

Forgot to add that Doug Goodyear of DCI also pitched in a grand to Coleman on 10/24/2007.

DCI and Akin Gump PACs are also Coleman contributors, though IMHO the individual donations are the most telling.

In one of its stories about the Iowa Future Fund, the Des Moines Register mentioned Holtzman Vogel:

"According to copies of the advertising invoices provided by the Iowa Democratic Party, the ad time was purchased by Mentzer Media Services of Baltimore, a GOP firm that has worked for Iowa candidates.

Mentzer purchased advertising time for Republican Jim Nussle's 2006 gubernatorial campaign. According to the records, contacts for some of the current ad purchases include employees of Holtzman Vogel, a Washington, D.C.-based firm that also was retained by the Nussle campaign in 2006.

Neither company returned calls seeking information on who purchased the ads. Former aides to Nussle also did not return calls."

I sent some emails to a couple of Iowa and Minnesota bloggers, asking if they can be of any help with this research. I also sent an email to Eric Peterson at his Summit Farms email address but I haven't heard from him.

Check out Rastetter's state contributions at FollowTheMoney.org. He gave tons of money to Republicans but this year, he gave $25k to Governor Culver. I am sure this was a matter of practicality.

In a previous comment, I mentioned that Rastetter might not want Dems to know how much money he is funneling to Republicans, hence IFF and AFF.

If AFF and IFF are run like the American Center For Voting Rights, firms like Holtzman Vogel, Mehlman Vogel Castagnetti, Akin Gump etc will all be paid for services rendered.

The thing about 501s is that we don't get the 990s until months after year end and we won't ever know who the donors are.

Art Levine in the American Prospect covers some of the damage done to a free electorate by Alex Vogel, Mark "Thor" Hearne, Jill Holtzman Vogel, Bruce Mehlman and so on.

These people will do anything and everything for a buck and they will be looking to make a lot of money in this election.


americanfuturefund.com and iowafuturefund.com were both registered privately on 10/19/2007. What is odd is that they are on different networks, according to Robtex.

The AFF and IFF youtube videos were posted on 2/25/08 and 2/26/08.

I checked the whereabouts of some of the people named in Paul Kiel's original post.

David Kochel, formerly an advisor to the Romney campaign, owns JDK Marketing & Publishing along with Jennifer Dean. Marketrak.com, an online project manager, is part of JDK Marketing.

Edward T. Tobin III, formerly executive director of the Republican Governors Association, is a partner in Wilmer Hale's fairly new Public Policy and Strategy Group.

Ben Ginsberg, former counsel to the Bush-Cheney campaign, is a partner in Patton Boggs's public policy and lobbying group.

We already know about Holtzman Vogel.

All of these firms could be looking to make money through American Future Fund and Iowa Future Fund.


I posted a Daily Kos diary about American Future Fund and Iowa Future Fund here.

I also posted at the TPM Cafe.

To get an idea about the ethanol industry in Iowa, read this WaPo story, "Corn Farms Prosper, but Subsidies Still Flow". I like this part about Bruce Rastetter's big party last summer:

"To celebrate a banner year, Hawkeye founder and chief executive Bruce Rastetter pulled out the stops for his annual midsummer bash. Several hundred politicians, businessmen and farmers mingled at his richly landscaped hilltop estate, and Sen. Charles E. Grassley (R-Iowa) made his entrance in a wagon pulled by Rastetter's team of Percheron draft horses."

Wow, very impressive work!

Bill Orally has to be a major funding source.

avatar

Slimy Norman.

Oh yeah, he's very independent.

If you define independent as "having ones head buried inside George W. Bush's rectum."

avatar

I believe the current FEC process is broken because of lack of staff. As long as the stalemate persists (congress won't confirm Bush's odious nominees), the FEC can investigate, but cannot take action on violations. Eventually, after the elections, there could be lots of fines, but who will care then? I'm not sure whether such shadowy groups will even have any assets to pay fines by that time. If my understanding is accurate, we're in for one hell of a political advertising season.

avatar

I like Al. I enjoyed him on the radio, even though he talked too much and interrupted his guests. He still demonstrated a good heart and a considerate soul. I hope he can perform in debates with Coleman, but I worry because I heard he didn't do all that well in the Dem debates. He should know his stuff, as he interviewed practically all authorities on major issues while he was on the air. And let's give him credit for being in on the ground floor with Air America when there was no one, and I mean literally no one, taking on the right wing in the media. Norm is a true chameleon; he'll do and say anything to get attention and stay in office. I met him as a prosecutor and he was obvious even then. One time he interrupted a whole room full of lawyers and their wives just so he could direct their attention to a news item where he expected to be on camera. He only switched to Republican because he knew he needed to side step his boss, Skip Humphrey, to run for governor. Now there's gratitude for you. Now the Pentagon is 200 billion dollars over charged (by Cheney's buddies no doubt) and Norm didn't conduct one damned hearing while it was going on. He should be horsewhipped with that. Ghostrider 20

avatar

I've met and spoken with both Senator Coleman and Al Franken, and I like both of them for very different reasons. My sense is that this is going to be a very close race, but I predict that Senator Coleman comes out on top. While Senator Coleman, a former Democrat, is toxic to most liberals I believe that Al Franken's acerbic tongue will make it easy for Coleman to paint Franken as too partisan, too angry to represent Minnesota's "nice' voters.

avatar

Norm Coleman has been nothing but a water carrier for Bush/Cheney. If Al's "acerbic tongue" is used to cut him to shreds, most Minnesotans will love it.

Articles like this and the concerns in the comments that follow are precisely what gets me very cynical about all the wanton optimism being expressed by democrats these days.

Seriously, this kind of political subterfuge from republican dirty tricksters is not only going to become much more prominent but should be anticipated and with the FEC the neutered body that it is, and Bush's stooges still in charge of the machinations of the justice department and prosecutors I'm really not sure how anyone can have too much hope. The MSM is no different than it was four years ago, and will just facilitate controversy when these groups come out with blatantly incendiary and false charges as they most certainly have in the works. Who is going to be watching out for when that 527 attack ad comes out that will scream bullshit of BO being directly in bed with Farrakhan or the Weather Underground and Faux and the MSM start their high gear hyper histrionics?

Can anyone think of anyone from the left capable of wading in the slime with these guys and keeping them on the defensive these days? No. The only one that dirty on the left is the ice queen herself and there's no reason to think she'll be inclined to engage with them after losing the nomination, since it's highly doubtful that BO will make her his VP choice with her massive negatives, nor any reason to think she'd accept even if offered.

Are there any shadowy operators on the left any more? Dick Morris has gone permanently over to the dark side. Rove will certainly be going to his play book as a fully engaged consultant behind the scenes. If BO is really as smart a politician as he seems to be a person, maybe he can pull off a major coup and draft Mark McKinnon onto his campaign staff. But unless that happens, who is going to be his attack dog or act as his shadowy operatives so he can remain above the fray and maintain being 'presidential'?!? JFK had his brother Bobby wade in the dirt and mud for him while he was able to float above the fray.

Who does BO have that will be operating anything close to the the black-ops network of a Holtzmann/Vogel/Resin's shadowy groups out there? To see this stuff lurking, it's hard to remain positive.

Yes, but Al has devoted countless time to our troops entertainment wise for years, he is SO well informed and smart, and maybe if you knew Coleman like you do Franken, you wouldn't care for him either.

To hyperRevue re: Al, see above.

Good point, independentmeans. I'm confident you're right about that.

avatar

If Coleman were running against a generic Democrat, I think this would be a tougher race for him because then it would be all about his closeness with a very unpopular President Bush. While Franken is very smart and very well informed, his persona is just not very Minnesotan. I'm not saying its hopeless for Franken, but he is going to need to keep the snarkiness in check and hope for some significant Obama coattails.

Post a Comment

Tag Cloud

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address