« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Not-Technically-An-NIE NIE Won't Be Released

We've been wondering whether the public will be seeing the results of the intelligence community's hard work on assessing the situation in Iraq. Turns out (not surprisingly, no). Spencer is the bearer of bad news:

For weeks, analysts within the 16-agency U.S. intelligence community have been toiling to complete an assessment of the situation in Iraq. This morning, it finally went to the Hill: the Senate and House intelligence committees, and the leadership in both chambers, are the proud owners of an update to the August 23, 2007 National Intelligence Estimate. The Senate Foreign Relations Committee received a briefing on it. But you'll never see it.

According to an administration official with knowledge of the intelligence process, this morning's intelligence document isn't itself a National Intelligence Estimate. "It's not a formal report," the official said, "it's more or less an assessment memo, an update to policy makers."

So does the intelligence community think that the political situation in Iraq is in a hopeless deadlock? That the security gains of the past few months are meaningful and lasting? Well, I guess we'll just have to take the word of Gen. David Petraeus and Ambassador Ryan Crocker when they testify before Congress next week.


7 Comments

| Leave a comment

So to recap.

"National Intelligence Estimate/NIE" a/k/a "a formal report" = releaseable

"National Intelligence Estimate Update Memo" a/k/a "not a formal report" a/k/a "more or less an assessment memo" but still having the same information as an NIE just a different color cover (or maybe it was printed on an HP instead of a Xerox) = not releaseable

They should have just marked it "unclassified - but sensitive" or "not for unofficial release" or any other of their meaninless non-classification classifications that keeps things from falling into the public's hands.

This will be leaked by Friday.

This may be a FOIA opportunity.

user-pic

The Bush administration would have already leaked this to the press if the NIE estimate supported what they have been telling the American people. Just as obvious, the report is being withheld because it contridicts the spin being put out by the Whitehouse.

user-pic

Exactly right DallasNE.

This report has to be bad news for Bush's ambitions else it would headline the NYT today.

So long as our oil is under their sand, Exxon's military strike force will be in Iraq.

You think you're only paying $3.50 a gallon for that gasoline? Heh, don't forget the Pentagon budget.

A major mistake not to release @ least a summary, since now the American public can assume the resounding negativity of what this particular NIE says regarding the Iraq situation.

BBpdx is right. It'll be coming out regardless, & not in a form McConnell & Co can control- these lame ducks are without the clout to stop it.

user-pic

BBpdx, yes is right. Stay tuned to Wikileaks, eh?

Leave a comment

Tag Cloud

Masthead

Editor
Josh Marshall

Reporter-Bloggers
Zachary Roth
Kate Klonick

Researchers
Matt Berman
Natalie Sherman



Subscribe to this blog's feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address