TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Today's Must Read

Nevada Gov. Jim Gibbons' still has two years left in office.

But Gibbons' divorce is getting nastier by the day, and many GOP operatives are getting more concerned about saving their party than his marriage.

The Las Vegas Sun reports on the latest in the court battle:

Wednesday's filing by Dawn Gibbons' attorney Cal Dunlap, a former district attorney who is said to love a public fight, is ostensibly an argument to open the now-sealed divorce filing. In fact, however, it's clearly part of an aggressive media strategy to paint the governor as a cold, philandering liar.

"Despite his disingenuous, shallow, and transparent protestations that his relationship with another man's wife is a mere friendship, his infatuation and involvement with the other woman is the real, concealed and undisclosed reason for his voluntary departure from the marriage," the court filing states.

Gibbons has been refusing to comment about the divorce proceedings. A judge has sealed the case, but Dawn Gibbon's attorney released her filings because of the "importance of the First Amendment and the public's right to have open access to the courts and court proceedings."

The court documents did not identify the woman Gibbons is accused of having an affair with. But local reporters in Nevada did. The Las Vegas Review Journal reports:

The woman is Kathy Karrasch, said several sources who requested anonymity, the wife of Reno podiatrist C. Craig Karrasch.

Recent phone records obtained by the Review-Journal show a single call placed from the governor's cell phone to Kathy Karrasch's cell phone on Jan. 10.

A family member who answered the cell phone Wednesday said Kathy Karrasch and her husband have separated for reasons unrelated to the governor.

The Reno Gazette-Journal offers more details about the relationship.

Karrasch lives a few blocks away from the Gibbonses' Reno home. ... Jim Gibbons was seen having dinner with Karrasch and three other people May 10 at the Atlantis Sky Terrace Oyster and Sushi Bar. He also attended the Galena High School play on May 1 to see Karrasch's daughter perform.

Although he attended the play alone, he spent the second half standing with Karrasch in the back of the room while she filmed her daughter, according to video footage provided to the Reno Gazette-Journal.

Gibbons' spokesman Ben Kieckhefer said the governor attended the play at the invitation of an unnamed neighbor.

In previous interviews, Gibbons has maintained he and Karrasch are "friends."

We've been reporting Gibbons' run of embarrassing political moves in recent months. The investigation of his ties to a defense contractor still lingers. But the locals in Nevada say the final straw was when Gibbons tried to get his wife evicted from the governors' mansion.

The Sun reports:

Republicans say serious discussions are taking place around the state among political and business leaders about how to extricate the party from the increasingly messy divorce proceeding between Dawn and Jim Gibbons. They say Jim Gibbons has handled the matter poorly by attempting to evict the first lady from the mansion and not settling the matter quickly and quietly.

And the implications could reach far beyond Nevada, one Republican tells the New York Times

"This absolutely could depress Republicans who are already depressed," said Chuck Muth, a Republican political consultant and blogger. "This could hurt McCain's ability to hold on to Nevada. It could also affect the chances of (Rep.) Jon Porter (R-Nev.) to get re-elected."

[Late Update: The previous version of this post referring to Gibbons as a practicing Mormon has been corrected. Gibbons was raised in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but has described himself as a non-observant Mormon.]


41 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Family values.

"Must Read"?

This is the personal life of a politician I never heard of before. No public policy implications at all -- just pure marital scandal-mongering. Juicy? Maybe. Important? No way.

I expect better from TPM.

user-pic

You've never heard of him? This is the guy who was accused of assaulting a drunk woman a couple of days before the 2006 election! There were 9/11 tapes and missing surveillance footage! And then he won the election!

user-pic

Don, you would be right, if only Gibbons weren't a member of the so-called "party of family values". When you stand with people saying that what goes on in a person's private life does matter in politics and government, then yes, your own private conduct becomes fair play.

Especially when it exemplifies the real Republican motto: "Good for me, but not for thee".

The moral majority shows us the way again. Realy I do not know this governor nor franky care about his past transgressions in his personal life. His no former wife deciding to go public with this is honorable in the sense that she feels the public has the right to know but also feels like airing her dirty laundry in public, maybe a little springer-esque. Of course this can not be good for Republicans in the state, with the NJ Rep Fossella, Guiliani's own marital issues, Bob Schaffer shenanigans in the mariana Islands, McCain's frequent mis-statements regarding facts pertaining to foreign policy, which is supposed to be his strong suit, it is looking like the red-meat that Republicans always talk about is their own. Good ridance to bad governance and hopefully we will be ablt to look back at this time in our history as a moment which was the beginning of the end for the neo-conservatives and many of the Republican counter-parts effort to ruin this country through privatization that leads to economic instability and equality and a lack of accountability and integrity by those that offer themselves as 'leaders'!

Let's kick their ass this November! Let's see some progress for the progressive agenda!

Whoa, hold on there podna. Vito Fossella is from Staten Island, which, while situated uncomfortably close to NJ, is actually part of New York. For the record, the Garden State denounces and rejects both Rep. Fossella and Staten Island.

THIS IS EXCELLENT NEWS!!! FOR HILLARY!!!!

And why, exactly, is it relevant that the Governor is "a practicing Mormon"? If he were a practicing Methodist, or a practicing Jew, would that bit of information be equally newsworthy in this context?

well said.


Pardon me while I cover for Bill the Cat. He's busy sitting on the pot.

Don asks some good questions. Must Read?? Feh. Mormon? Who cares?

But I think I see some potential defendants who might need my services....

Divorce lawyer who violates gag order and releases his filings? For the sake of the First Amendment? Yeah, right. The judge is likely gonna smack him down. Maybe even toss out his case.

The L.V. Review-Journal just happens to "obtain" the guv's cell-phone records? How'd they do that? Dumpster diving? Lying to the phone company (theft by fraud, aka pretexting)?

Yep, I'm waiting for my phone to ring. Lots of people in Nevada are gonna need a defense attorney.

Steve, the story doesn't say, but it's possible that the story is referring to the governor's *state* cell-phone records, which are public in many states, not his private number. I don't know; I'm just suggesting that this is a possible scenario in which the reporter(s) got the info in question while breaking no law.

I appreciate the correction. Honestly, though, I don't see what difference it makes whether the guy is a practicing Mormon or a lapsed Holy Roller.

A divorce is news? In Nevada, of all places? If he were caught in the arms of a high-rent 22-year-old prostitute -- OK, that'd be news. But here this guy is caught red-handed, attending the school play of a neighbor's kid, actually talking to the kid's mother even as she videotapes the performance. The horror...

This may be of local interest to some easily scandalized Nevadans, but no way would TPM promote this story if the politician in question were a Democrat.

I don't know, maybe the guy's a jerk, and schadenfreude is the proper response. But to me this story only makes him more sympathetic.

It probably would be. As an example it is one thing to just be Catholic by accident of birth. It is another thing to be a practicing Catholic as it implies you actually share those beliefs.

user-pic

"This absolutely could depress Republicans who are already depressed".

Depressed Repoublicans in swing states IS excellent news.

Skeptical readers, forget not that Jim Gibbons was also a member of the US House of Representatives from 1996-2004.

While in the House, he was pals with Rep. Jim Doolittle and Rep. Richard Pombo, two guys who did not have the interests of the American people first in mind.

He left Congress before the the Abramoff stench and the abusive GOP leadership became liabilities for the Republican Party, so he avoided that scrutiny.

While in Congress, Gibbons wife was a consultant, receivng payments from defense contractors in his district. Coincedentally, the company was called Sierra Nevada -- while their good friends, the Doolittles had a company named Sierra Dominion. The Gibbons' and the Doolittles used to vacation together at Tahoe.

The Doolittles' company was used to plow campaign funds into their personal pockets -- and to accept funds from Abramoff.

I bet the wife has a lot to say. Much of it potentially damaging to the GOP -- which is why they've publicly said Gibbons is ON HIS OWN.

user-pic

Jim Gibbons has something in common with Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush: none of the three of them are particularly bright, to the extent that all three seem to suffer (or have suffered) from some sort of obvious cognitive disfunction. And yet, the Republican machine managed to foist them on the public anyway.

In a group setting in May 2006, in the course of defending Bush's tax cuts for the rich, I heard Jim Gibbons say, "That's a lesson John F. Kennedy learded in 1964 -- tax cuts are good for the economy," to which I promptly replied, "John F. Kennedy didn't learn anything in 1964 -- he was dead." He then stopped interacting completely with the audience of visiting students and constituents. He just shut down.

I later learned that he had an extensive history of verbal gaffes much worse than this, gaffes which continued through the guberbatorial campaign and into the governor's office.

I don't care that he's a Mormon (that just makes him an even bigger "family values" hypocrite). I do care that he is a mentally-disabled pawn of -- who? I don't know. But they don't have the best interests of Nevada or the U.S. at heart. He is incompetent.

I wouldn't hire him as a night manager of a 7-11.

user-pic

Must read? Are you kidding me? I couldn't care less about the Nevada governor's sex partners. If David Kurtz thinks this is a MUST READ, perhaps he should be working for Fox News.

I understand where you're coming from, Jim, but I don't think it's fair to have two different sets of rules, one for Republicans and another for Democrats.

Larry Craig? OK, the guy was a flaming moralist hypocrite. If Gibbons was prominent for attacking a political opponent in the guise of a holier-than-thou family man, then maybe...

I don't know. My sympathies could be totally misplaced. Maybe Gibbons is really a bad guy. He's a Republican, so I almost certainly wouldn't have voted for him. But I never heard of him before, and the only news here is that his wife wants their divorce to be messy and public. If that's a "must read," it's a slow news day.

Sorry, that reply was meant for jlindquist above at 12:36 PM.

user-pic

Jeez, I never thought I'd see the day when you couldn't laugh at corrupt Republicans without concern trolls sniffing that the Muckraker shouldn't cover GOP illicit affairs.

It was certainly newsworthy when the drunken bum assaulted a woman at night in a parking lot on the eve of his election and then got his buddies to cover it up.

Gibbons is under investigation for taking bribes. The affair is just more evidence of the governor's moral turpitude.

Remember the $100k bribe that was purportedly passed to Gibbons by a supporter when they were on a cruise together? No one complained about the photos from the cruise being published here.

If his wife gets ticked off enough, we might get lucky and she will throw Gibbons under a bus. She was involved in his financial affairs and knows where the bodies are buried.

I did a little digging and it wasn't to hard to come up with questions about the governor's intiative, Education First.

The day TPM Muckraker stops publishing this stuff is the day I stop reading it.

Here's hoping for that bus to be in the right place at the right time.

I agree with Mrs P.

GOP loyalist like to hide their scarlet letter, (R), and pretend Gibbons(R) is some sort of unknown. They'll even go so far as to fault TPM Muckraker by saying to be news worthy it would require a 22 year old high rent prostitute. Does this mean a bj by two bit whore, would not?

Gibbons is not new to TPM Muckraker. He is featured over two dozen times including this gem.
http://tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com/2007/05/smile_youre_under_federal_inve.php

I'm not a closet GOPer, and I haven't given a lot of thought to what a hooker's minimum age, price and services rendered would be for newsworthiness.

Standing next to a neighbor, at her kid's school play, just doesn't quite rise to that level, in my opinion.

A Republican Governor's divorce is getting messy. What is the news value here? None I can see, just the entertainment value of ugly gossip.

Don, I just don't find you credible. You just said, "I'm not a closet GOPer, and I haven't given a lot of thought to what a hooker's minimum age, price and services rendered would be for newsworthiness." Earlier at 12:57 you said, "If he were caught in the arms of a high-rent 22-year-old prostitute -- OK, that'd be news."

To be honest I would never expect that you would admit that you are a GOPer. That's par for the course these days for those of you who carry that scarlet letter (R). ;)

This is amusing -- defending my credibility as a Democrat to a space alien. And Mrs. P thinks I'm a "concern troll" -- I don't know what that is, but it sounds bad. Fortunately, I've blogged here for a while; you can click on my name if you seriously doubt my bona fides.

My mention at 12:57 of "a high-rent 22-year-old hooker" was, I thought, a pretty unmistakable reference to the recent problems of Elliot Spitzer vis-a-vis Ashley Alexandra Dupre.

For what it's worth, I will stipulate that Gov. Gibbons may be a notorious villain, a scoundrel and a buffoon. That doesn't change the fact that this particular "must-read" news story didn't lay a glove on him. In fact, it had the opposite of its intended effect, stirring up sympathy for the devil.

user-pic

Don,

You may very well be a long time reader but my guess is that most TPM Muckraker regulars like me think the Gibbons story is a hoot.

Anyone who voted to impeach Bill Clinton should be nailed to the wall for his own personal transgressions and Gibbons, despite his reservations, voted for impeachment.

How could you forget the sanctimonious crap we had to listen to for two long, painful years and still hear, for that matter? I will never, ever forget forgoing Christmas shopping on a Saturday in December to watch one of the most obscene spectacles in American history.

Not one single Republican ever stood up and said what was happening to Bill clinton was wrong.

Fuck Gibbons and fuck the Republicans. I want to know every single time one of them gets his dick sucked by someone other than his wife so I can tell the rest of the world about it.

But really, do you want to be awakened every time some "unnamed sources who requested anonymity" out some hapless non-public figure, and the news carries footage of her brazenly standing next to the Governor.

You're still angry at Ken Starr. Me, too. The difference is, I don't want to spend my life acting like Ken Starr.

user-pic

Hapless non-public figure?

Are you joking? This so-called hapless woman is married and to a doctor no less. She knows the score.

What the hell do you think she expected to happen when she began an affair with a married governor who drunkenly assaulted a woman in a parking lot and is under investigation for corruption? Privacy?

Get real.

And no, I'm not still mad at Ken Starr. Starr was just a flunky who was paid to nail the president and he fucked it up. Everyone ended up hating Starr and feeling sorry for Clinton.

No, I despise every single Republican who let Senator Alphonse D'Amato investigate Whitewater for six fucking years. I'm from Long Island and I know Senator Al ranks as one of the most crooked senators in American history. The Republicans must have thought this was hilarious but I didn't.

I would happily destroy the lives of every single Republican who served in Congess since 1992. Not one of them ever stood up and said that what Richard Mellon Scaife and the rest of the right wing was doing was wrong.

Nope, I'll never get over the Republicans trying to make a mockery of the presidency. Nor will I ever get over their attempt to overthrow a legitimately elected government.

How could anyone concerned about justice in this country forget Rehnquist's gold stripes on his robe? Pompous asshole.

Who wasn't alarmed about the fate of our country after watching the Republicans stage an attempted coup?

I'm not surprised that a lot of people thought a Republican government was behind 9-11 after watching the Republicans in action for the previous ten years. They seemed capable of doing anything to advance their cause including starting a phony war. Which they did.

Jim Gibbons is a scumbag who voted to impeacb the president of the United States for lying about an affair. A couple of weeks ago, Gibbons lied to the press when asked about his affair.

If Jim's adultery helps elect Democrats in Nevada in 2008, great. I hope Gibbons sticks to his guns and runs again in 2010.

user-pic

BTW, Larry Flynt has my eternal gratitude for giving Democrats the only laughs they had during the dark days.

Well, my mistake. I thought this woman was entitled to some measure of privacy in her private life.

But if, as you say, she's married to a doctor...

And, as you were too delicate to point out, not just any doctor. She's married to... a podiatrist!!

Well, then, touche. Shut me up.

I, like Don in Seattle, have strong Democratic credentials, but wanted to post a comment about the gold stripes on Justice Rehnquist's robe. It relates to his light opera singing hobby, I believe (he loved Gilbert and Sullivan and performed in a number of G&S productions), and in my opinion was actually cute, and the antithesis of pompous. Although I did not agree with his judicial philosophy or with most of his opinions in important cases, he was a very nice man in the courtroom and his willingness as the Chief to depart from tradition and wear the funny gold stripes I think was very disarming

user-pic

There you go, I learned something new about the impeachment today.

The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court wasn't a pompous asshole, he was a fucking idiot who was thrilled to be center stage in the light comedy tentatively entitled "Death to Democracy."

If you think his gold stripes were amusing, you are a fucking idiot.

After his featured role in the impeachment of Bill Clinton, Mr. Fucking Nice Guy went on to star in Bush vs. Gore, thereby singlehandedly wrecking his own country.

I'll concede pompous but not asshole.

Give me an ornery s.o.b. who has respect for the law and the citizens of this country over a nice guy any day of the week.


user-pic

You owe "Don in Seattle" an apology for calling him a liar simply because you don't like his point-of-view and can't imagine that anyone other than the enemy could disagree with you.

Sigh, I got a feeling its going to be a LONG two years.

JJ
http://www.Ultimate-Anonymity.com

user-pic

"[Gibbons] Standing next to a neighbor, at her kid's school play, just doesn't quite rise to that level, in my opinion."

You are correct. Video of the governor attending a school play, in and of itself, is not newsworthy. But that isn't the scandal -- that's just the media visually putting a face to "the other woman," who otherwise has not been a public figure. (The local press has been sitting on rumors of this affair for months.)

Perhaps this is not eligible for "must-read" status for a national audience, but I sort of enjoy knowing the buffoonery of Jim Gibbons is finally getting national attention. I have to suffer several direct consequences of living in the state run by The Nation's Worst Governor.

user-pic

I think it is important to know that a person who runs his public campaign on "family values," and attacking others as not having "family values," and gets elected on the implicit promise that he will comport himself in keeping with "family values," is a hypocrite who won election by lying to the electors.

The electors have the absolute right to know they were swindled out of their vote by a liar and hypocrite.

I might feel sympathy for his wife and her husband; but am I to feel sympathy for the adulterers? Were they compassionate to his wife and her husband by violating their their "family values" vows?

If we can be put through years of baseless smears against Clinton, and an impeachment which was essentially a beef that the BJ didn't result in anyone's death, then I think we can stand the releif of some actual truth that exposes the mindsets and methods of the members of that lynch mob. Payback is a bitch -- even worse when the payback is caused by oneself; but we know who began the cycle.

From now on, whenever I hear a Republican talk about "family values," I'm gonna put on a pilot suit (I won't need the codpiece) and yell:

"Bring 'em on!"

user-pic

did i mention that governor gibbons is governor only because dawn stood up (or down, i guess, depending on your politics and perspective) and stood by her man while he faced the philandering and assault complaints just before the election. if she hadn't been visible and vocal in support of his character, honeesty integrity, republicanness, i think he could have been defeated.

did i mention the man is licensed for concealed/carry for 8 or 9 or 10 different handguns? true, no political implications, just something 99% of nevada aspires to. interesting image/concept though, think, all of them at the same time.

"practicing mormon" would definitely be relevant, differrent in nevada though than anywhere else.

oh, yeah, and he doesn't know diddly about running a state government.

all of which will come together in something resembling responsoble journalism. maybe before his elected time in office is over. maybe not.

Mrs. P--your diatribe sounds like me. If you were Ms. P I'd propose marriage, sight unseen.

He sounds like a perfect Republican. What's the problem?

I am new at this but it seems to me that a must read is whatever Josh deems it to be. When any one of us start our own blog and spend hours and hours on the project then we can decide what a must read will be. I agree with most here that this is a great opportunity to dig the knife in a little deeper and have a real hoot at the same time. Lighten up Don!

user-pic

I'm getting a little tired of folks portraying Bill Clinton as some sort of victimized saint. The guy lied to a federal grand jury, and to the American people, while a sitting president. In the process, his disregard for the rule of law raised the bar for the next set of jerks to occupy the executive.
Nixon was nearly impeached for a cover-up of political shenanigans. Only his resignation prevented it from happening. Clinton lied to cover up an extra-marital affair, and the proceedings went to a vote. Now we have wanton disregard for the Constitution and the separation of powers, illegal wiretapping (admitted on national TV), and plunging the nation into an unjustified war; but the nation's leaders are so scared of impeachment proceedings that even those who take their oath seriously cannot stand on principle, but take the path of least resistance.
People forget that there was cause for impeachment, just as there was cause for the Democrats being swept out the door in '94. Just because the Republicans have proven themselves to be much more blatant thieves operating on a much grander scale doesn't make the Democratic leaders clean - it's simply a matter of comparing the Big Leaguers to Triple A ballplayers.
Gibbons is news because he is another failed leader. It's time for us to find leaders who are worthy of us. Or maybe we have...

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address