TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Right-Wing Pundit On Voter Fraud Claim: Never Mind

Here's a funny example of how "voter-fraud" hysteria is starting to make some conservatives look kind of foolish.

In a post Friday on the website of the conservative magazine National Review, Jim Geraghty touted the New Mexico GOP's no-longer-operative claim that 28 people had voted fraudulently in a Democratic primary in June.

Then, attacking Adam Serwer of The American Prospect, who in an earlier post had questioned Geraghty's obsession with vote fraud, Geraghty wrote:

Now, unless A. Serwer thinks that there is actually a registered voter named "Duran Duran" in New Mexico, he ought to refrain from sputtering that those who disagree with him are 'racist' and 'paranoid.'

The person who is "Duran Duran" almost certainly voted under their real name, and thus got two votes in the primary. God knows how many of those 27 others exist; for all we know, one person might have cast all of them. Anybody who voted once had their vote diluted by the guy who cheated to vote two to twenty-seven times.

Geraghty sourced the Duran Duran claim, via link, to a column on the conservative web site Townhall.com, which described an Associated Press report that we weren't able to find. (What appears to be the original AP story on the GOP's claims contained no such detail.)

But it looks like what Geraghty and Townhall thought was a cut-and-dried example of fraudulent voting was no such thing. Some time later, Geraghty, was forced to correct the record, crossing out the quote above and adding the following update below his post:

I am floored by the fact that the white pages for Albuquereque, New Mexico has a listing for "Duran Duran." Mea culpa.

And sure enough.

The larger point is that, as we noted earlier, since Friday, ACORN has produced election officials to confirm that the "fraudulent" voters cited by the GOP were in fact valid.

Looks like both Republicans and conservative pundits might want to be a little more careful before throwing around claims of voter fraud. Not that we're holding our breath.


14 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Duran Duran is the evil villain in the comic strip and film "Barbarella". Just sayin'.

user-pic

I bet they thought this guy was a fake as well -
http://newmedia.funnyjunk.com/pictures/batman_bin_suparman.jpg

user-pic

OK... so he lives in Albuquerque. But is he hungry? Like de wolf?

user-pic

It's New Mexico.

Hambriento como el lobo.

user-pic

We'll hold off for the Navajo translation.

user-pic

This only matters if you think that they are crying voter fraud because they think there is some. They know that there isn't. They are just trying to keep the media and Democrats on the defensive while they try to fix the polls and run their vote caging racist ass schemes. This is a redirect tactic.

Speaking of Duran Duran, when can we expect the some Republican Girls on Film? We all love a good sex scandal!

user-pic

The song "Election Day" was by Arcadia, not Duran Duran.

I know, same singer, same guitar player, but it's altogether different.

user-pic

So as I understand it, trying to stop Duran Duran from voting would be a felony, right? I'm sure all these folks are going to apologize for advocating a felony.

user-pic

My sister graduated in 1959 at a high school in Albuquerque and one of her classmates name was David David. Wouldn't they also go nuts with that real person's name? I do not know if he still lives in NM.

user-pic

"Her name is Rio and she dances on the sand
Just like that river twists across a dusty land
And when she shines she really shows you all she can
Oh Rio, Rio dance across the Rio Grand
Her name is Rio she don't need to understand
And I might find her if I'm looking like I can
Oh Rio, Rio hear them shout across the land
From mountains in the north down to the Rio Grande
Do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do......"

Wrong state: they should have been worried about Texas.

user-pic

Duran *is* a common surname in New Mexico. I live in NM, and when I read the name 'Duran Duran' in the initial story, I thought it could possibly be the real name of a real voter.

user-pic

Yep. I worked at a company where a guy whose last name was 'Duran' worked--he had nine brothers and sisters. I wouldn't be surprised if one of his relatives was named 'Duran Duran'...not that uncommon a name at all.

user-pic

Funny as this is, it highlights a more serious point - that these claims of fraud, and efforts to match data, tend to have a more significant negative effect on persons with names that are not considered "traditional," and there's often a racial effect. On Latinos, for example, who use 2 last names (that was gonna be my guess of the Duran Duran thing), or African-Americans with unusual name spellings. Just look what's happening in Florida.


http://www.heraldtribune.com/article/20081018/ARTICLE/810180341/-1/NEWSSITEMAP
Law rejects many voters

By Todd Ruger

Published: Saturday, October 18, 2008 at 1:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Saturday, October 18, 2008 at 1:19 a.m.

A state voter verification law has rejected almost 9,000 new voter registrations in Florida for this presidential election, including 256 in Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte Counties.

Of those local registrations, more than four times as many Democrats as Republicans had their registration rejected since the law went into effect Sept. 8. More than a third were minorities, according to a state database released this week.

Those numbers match statewide trends for the law, often called "no match, no vote," which compares information from the voter registration to other state databases in a search for bad registrations.

The search flagged 8,867 voter registrations statewide, more than half of which came from blacks and Hispanics, while nearly half were Democrats.

Those voters still have until the election to show additional proof they are legitimate voters. Otherwise, they can vote by provisional ballot on Election Day and make the case in the next two days.

In the meantime, election officials will look at those registrations to determine why there was a discrepancy with the voter's name or a number -- either the driver's license number or the last four digits of the Social Security number.

It is not surprising that the law flags minorities, because of naming conventions in minority cultures, said Adam Skaggs of the Brennan Center for Justice at the New York University School of Law.

He used similar disproportionate results from the "no match" law to lead a legal challenge in 2007 that suspended the law until July, when a federal judge's court order upheld the law.

The reason for the results is that the black community has a high number of unique or derivative spellings of names, while Hispanics often use compound last names, Skaggs said.

"If the name is different than traditional spelling, and the government clerk types it in wrong, it's not going to match," Skaggs said.

"This is an issue that has been identified by scholars who study database matching well before it was used in voting."

Many times, a clerk made an error entering the name or someone used a nickname, state officials said.

The rejected registrations this year come from about 350,000 new registrations since Sept. 8.

Both political parties have been pushing new voter registrations for the upcoming presidential election in Florida, which is considered a close race.

Of the 256 registrations rejected in Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte counties, 121, or 47 percent, registered as Democrats; while 27, or 11 percent, registered as Republicans. The party of 58 people was listed as unknown.

In Sarasota County, where the U.S. Census estimates 6.8 percent of the population to be non-white, minorities accounted for 37 percent of the rejected registrations.

user-pic

So... if you ever want to assert I exist, please don't link to my white pages listing. I can imagine people calling Duran Duran from your post, and I'd rather that didn't happen to me.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address