« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Earlier Retirement Date Lets CEO Of Bailed-Out Bank Pocket $18 Million
Pro Publica notes the remarkable tale of Mack Whittle, the former CEO of South Financial Group, a South Carolina bank.
Whittle founded South Financial back in 1986, and under his leadership it grew to be the largest bank in the state. It expanded into North Carolina and Florida, eventually boasting $13.7 billion in total assets and 180 branch offices.
But Florida was one of the hardest hit states when the housing market crashed, and South Financial suffered. In early 2007, the bank's stock was above $26. Today it's at about $3.50. In the third quarter this year, South Financial posted a $25 million net loss.
In early September, Whittle announced that he planned to retire by year's end. A few weeks later, the financial crisis struck, and Congress soon passed a $700 billion bailout bill for banks. South Financial quickly announced that it would apply for bailout money.
Then, in a federal regulatory filing dated October 28, the bank quietly announced that Whittle had in fact stepped down as CEO a day earlier. No reason was given, and Whittle's successor as CEO had not yet been named.
So, why the expedited schedule? Perhaps because Whittle's new leaving date meant that he wasn't subject to limits on executive pay that were imposed as a condition of the bailout. As a result, Whittle enjoyed an $18 million send off, which includes a $9 million pension benefit, and perks like a $133,920 auto allowance and $75,000 for "financial planning." (He'll need some!)
And -- proving you can have your cake and eat it too -- earlier this week, it was announced that South Financial will receive $347 million from U.S. taxpayers as part of the bailout program.
South Carolina governor Mark Sanford, a Republican, has suggested that Whittle may have been "gaming the system" by moving up his retirement date, and has called for a Treasury Department investigation.
The bank said in a statement that the hefty package "reflected [Whittle's] 20 year career with [South Financial Group] as its founder and only CEO."
One expert on executive compensation told Pro Publica: "The whole idea was to avoid these types of arrangements" The Treasury "doesn't want the companies receiving taxpayer funds, terminating executives and having them walk away with excessive golden parachutes."
In this case -- and perhaps in others yet to be revealed? -- it looks like Treasury may have fallen short, to say the least.
Late Update: Given that its South Carolina governor Mark Sanford who's calling on the Treasury Department to investigate Whittle, it's worth noting that -- according to the Columbia paper The State (via Nexis) -- in 2006, Whittle was at the forefront of a group of state business executives who were dissatisfied with Sanford's policies toward business as governor, and backed a potential primary challenger, former state commerce secretary Bob Royall. Royall ultimately decided not to run, but it seems likely that Whittle isn't at the top of Sanford's Christmas card list, to say the least.













Meanwhile..the GOP Senators are busting unions (UAW) and refusing a LOAN to the auto industry..
November 20, 2008 12:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
It's not just the wages, but the pensions that bother the Republicans. Afterall, in the lone worker segment of industryies, those pensions have already been stolen, so why should UAW still have one? It's an argument standing on its head. The UAW should have one and so should have the lone workers. The real question is, why were the pensions allowed to be stolen and why was no one sent to jail?
November 20, 2008 12:32 PM | Reply | Permalink
This is criminal, it really is. There should be some way to rescind this.
And yes, Chabuka, I've read with GREAT interest how repubs are going after working people but are strangely silent in the face of this theft.
If I didn't know any better, I'd say that the whole repub resistance to the auto bailout is to break the unions. Just sayin'...
November 20, 2008 12:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
BINGO! It's all about busting the union.
November 20, 2008 12:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
Just like the car company CEOs flying their private jets to beg for our money - these guys have lived a life of privilege and power for so long that the most basic decencies are unthinkable to them. Like Joe Lieberman, they think they deserve to hold these postions. I say fire them all - I spent 25 years in the banking/morgage/insurance businesses and have said for years that American business is badly managed and only succeeds because America rules the world. Well, we don't rule the world anymore and as a nation we can't afford these incompetent, greedy men who have kept themselves and their buddies insulated from reality.
The executive who told me I couldn't take a half day to get my son started in a new school used to go golfing every Friday afternoon - he said he was 'networking'. This mentality has to go and soon!
November 20, 2008 12:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Actions like this smell mighty similar to insider trading.
November 20, 2008 12:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
You might say that Whittle's giving us a little "golden rain."
November 20, 2008 1:02 PM | Reply | Permalink
There's got to be enough gold in there to melt into a box of ammo.
GM, Ford or Chryco, bullets for the parachutes.
November 20, 2008 1:37 PM | Reply | Permalink
Or, as Elijah Cummings would say, "chumped again." If this is the only bailout bonanza story like this, I'll eat my 1040s.
The Constant Weader at www.RealityChex.com
November 20, 2008 1:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
Republicans feel it's indecent to pay hard working blue collar workers $50 an hour plus benefits but as for stealing $18 million ... SO WHAT? These CEOs work so hard at their golf games and pontificating about hard work and capitalism. Easy to be a capitalist when you take all the capital.
November 20, 2008 2:52 PM | Reply | Permalink