« previous | MUCK HOME | next »
Georgia's "Non-Citizen" Voting Controversy: A Recap
So let's briefly look back at what appears to have happened in the controversy over voting in Georgia this election cycle.
First, GOP Secretary of State Karen Handel, based on an interpretation of federal election law, purged around 50,000 newly registered voters from the rolls, based on discrepancies between the information on their voter registration form and that in state databases. About 5000 of those voters were purged because the state found that they had checked a box on their drivers license application indicating that they're non-citizens.
Voting-rights groups sued Handel, claiming that the purge violated federal voting laws, and that the procedure for identifying non-citizens was flawed. For instance, the plaintiff in the case, Jose Morales, had applied for his drivers license while a non-citizen, but had become a naturalized citizen before the election. Since the drivers database is not automatically updated in such cases, he was still flagged as a non-citizen.
Ultimately, a judge required Handel to send a letter to the voters flagged as non-citizens, informing them that their status was in question and notifying them that they could cast a provisional ballot. But if they didn't provide election officials with documents proving their citizenship, within a few days after the election, their ballots would be thrown out.
Many such voters -- in some counties, about two thirds -- did return with the correct documentation. But of course, many didn't, and some counties began throwing out ballots this week.
And the fact that so many did provide documentation only served to bolster the contention of voting-rights groups that the process for flagging voters had been badly flawed. That claim was further strengthened by the fact that the system now seems to have flagged not only naturalized citizens like Morales, but also U.S. born voters whose citizenship has never been in question. One of these voters, a veteran of the U.S. military who received Handel's letter telling her that her citizenship was in question, spoke to TPMmuckraker yesterday.
It's still not clear how many voters were wrongly flagged, and either had their ballots thrown out or were discouraged by Handel's letter from voting in the first place. The question is not academic, because a runoff vote in Georgia's U.S. Senate race, between Republican Saxby Chambliss and Democrat Jim Martin, is scheduled for December 2nd, after neither man gained 50 percent last week. The vote is expected to be extremely close, and voters who have been designated as non-citizens, correctly or incorrectly, will presumably be barred from casting conventional ballots once again.
Handel's office has said it's working on compiling those numbers, though it appears to be in no rush. We'll keep you posted on what we hear...

















Handel's excuse for an earlier instance of inaction that would have made it easier for people to vote was that Georgia is still under Voting Rights Act monitoring, so she couldn't make changes without the permission of the Justice Department (ignoring the fact that she could have easily gotten that permission if she'd asked.)
But since that is the case, when we have a Justice Department back in place that is actually interested in justice, can they please investigate and send some of these vote-suppressing bozos to jail?
November 12, 2008 12:48 PM | Reply | Permalink
There are a lot of things we need to fix nowadays, and voting is right at the top. How ridiculous is it to allow the Secretary of State, who is almost always partisan, to be the person in charge of certifying who can vote or not? In comparison to many people in the world, our whole voting system is "third worldish." How about getting together on October 1 and compiling the lists, sending everybody a letter that says you are good to go, or you are not, and here is what you need to bring if you are not. And, by the way, you vote between these dates at this precinct--a letter to every single registered voter. No errors, no misunderstandings. And the people who are challenged and determined by a bi-partisan committee, exactly the same number of members from each party.
November 12, 2008 2:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
The one-third of voters whose papers were flagged probably just couldn't get to govt. offices before the election. They didn't have much time to do so.
This is a very underhanded way to win an election, not what is usually meant when we are told that democracy is messy.
This is why talk about bipartisanship is so naive. Your opponent is busy caging your constituents at the polls, and you want to accomodate him/her?
November 12, 2008 2:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
What about the other 45,000 names purged? That is a MUCH bigger story. How many of them got timely or any notice? Have any complained? Let's have some real journalism along with muck!!
It's clear that the DMV citizenship check-off is not a useful indicator since it was wrong in at least 2/3 of cases, by your reports. What other problems are out there in GA?
"more than 50,000 registered Georgia voters who have been "flagged" because of a computer mismatch in their personal identification information"
November 12, 2008 4:11 PM | Reply | Permalink
Reading this from Australia I am stunned that the USA appears to have nothing like the Australian Electoral Commission. I stand open to correction here and would be grateful for any information to the contrary.
Given that you have a political cycle at Federal Level of elections every 2 years for the House and Presidential/HouselSenate every 4 years plus the need for elections to replace casual vacancies AND then a similar cycle for all elections at State and Local Government level, it seems both incredibly inefficient and potentially fraudulent to not have an independent body.
I came to the site as I was interested in why a run off for the US Senate seat was needed.
This article and the comments make interesting reading!
The AEC oversee all elections taking place in the Commonwealth of Australia at Federal, State,Territory and Local Government level. It also oversee any compulsory ballots that are enacted under Federal, State or Territory legislation.
The AEC website @ http://www.aec.gov.au/
November 12, 2008 7:08 PM | Reply | Permalink