TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Could Obama's Executive Order Help Pry Loose Bush Records?

Over at TPM, Josh and David have been mulling the significance of the executive order, issued today by President Obama, concerning the Presidential Records Act. Could it apply retroactively to previous administrations, making it easier to pry loose records that the Bush White House has fought to keep secret?

According to Anne Weismann, a lawyer for Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, the tentative answer is yes.

As David notes, the order says:

Going forward, anytime the American people want to know something that I or a former President wants to withhold, we will have to consult with the Attorney General and the White House Counsel, whose business it is to ensure compliance with the rule of law.

As a result, Weismann told TPMmuckraker, the order could affect any case in which the White House has claimed executive privilege over presidential (or, to be clear, vice presidential) records. Most important, it would subject those claims to review by the Justice Department. "It does have the potential to impact ongoing litigation," she said.

Weismann specifically cited the ongoing legal fight between the House Judiciary committee and the Bush White House, over documents relating to the US Attorney firings. Among other documents, Congress has been seeking a key memo written by a White House counsel, which might shed light on White House involvement in the firings.

Weismann told TPMmuckraker that that the order likely would not affect a lawsuit she had been working on, on behalf of CREW, which sought to compel Dick Cheney's office to hand over all his records to the National Archives. On Monday a judge declined to order Cheney to do so. Weismann said that case turned on an interpretation of the Presidential Records Act itself, rather than on a claim of executive privilege.

Still, it certainly seems possible that on his first full day in office, the new president has dealt significant a blow to the Bush administration's efforts to permanently keep information from the public. But a lot more questions than answers remain, and we've got calls out to some experts in executive privilege who might be able to shed further light on what Obama's order does and doesn't do.


5 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Bush should have declared himself President for Life when he had the chance.

user-pic

If no assertion of privilege has been made, it seems pretty clear that the decision would have to rest with the current executive. There can, as Obama said throughout the transition, be only one president at a time. If a previous president has asserted privilege, it might be more difficult for a subsequent one to withdraw that assertion, but there are many ways to skin a cat. And many degrees of aggressiveness and perseverance in pursuing a legal claim.

user-pic

Props to Obama, for giving the American public access to records...that affected their lives. Having read so many history books that were put on hold while gaining access to government files that would confirm or refute the known historical record.

Cornyn may be trying to stall the Holder nomination, thinking that the American public will forget about "torture" and previous administrations. As no GOP wants to look back to the previous administration (2 days ago). Maybe he thinks that Holder will end up being so busy that the thought of looking back into the records will be lost. Or maybe Cornyn is just the fall guy for the GOP

Now Cheney's "legislative status" will be put to the test if some inquisitive reporter goes after documentation about "torture".

user-pic

afisher ,
To quote Sir Doyle ,
"Come Watson the game is afoot "
Come to think about this would be a great way to get our very own newbie Matt Cooper back on his investigative reporter game - Let the FOIA's fall like rain - to wash these deserted but haunted bushcheney mean streets clean -

user-pic

And no doubt, once these Bush/Cheney papers are revealed, we will get to sift throught them as we have in the past?

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address