TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Sununu Sits On TARP Oversight Panel, And On Board Of Firm Owned By Bank That Administers TARP

John Sununu, who serves on the Congressional Oversight Panel monitoring the government's bailout program, has joined the board of a subsidiary to Bank of New York Mellon -- a firm that, in addition to receiving bailout funds, has been hired by the Treasury Department to administer the program.

Given that the Congressional Oversight Panel (COP) is charged broadly with assessing how the TARP program is working, in order to help Congress determine whether to continue injecting capital into the financial sector, the arrangement would appear to create a significant conflict of interest for the former New Hampshire GOP senator.

On Wednesday, the investment firm BNY ConvergEx Group announced that Sununu had joined its board of governors. "His experience as a thoughtful leader and champion of innovation makes him an ideal match for ConvergEx's entrepreneurial spirit," said company chairman Joseph Velli of Sununu.

According to its press release, the company is an affiliate of Bank of New York Mellon (BONY). Founded by Alexander Hamilton in 1784, BONY received $3 billion in TARP funds back in October -- less than some Wall Street firms, but not chump change.

Just as significantly, it was also picked to be the master custodian for the bailout funds. According to reports, that means it's charged with handling accounting and record-keeping for the program, and even with tracking limits on executive pay at banks that got TARP money.

Sununu was appointed to the COP by GOP Senate leader Mitch McConnell in December -- a little over a month after he was defeated by Democrat Jeanne Shaheen in his bid for reelection to the Senate.

Sununu's conflict, then, appears clear. As a member of the COP, he's in part responsible for evaluating whether taxpayers got a good deal through TARP, and for assessing whether Treasury and the banks are doing enough to track the bailout money, as well as whether banks are using the money to make loans, as they were supposed to. On the broadest level, COP's job is to help Congress figure out whether the TARP program is working as it should, and how to adjust it going forward. It's not hard to see how that responsibility could conflict with his activities as a member of the board of a company that both administers the TARP program, has received funds from it, and could potentially be in line for more.

In his work on the panel so far, Sununu has hardly been an advocate for taking a hard line on the banks. Earlier this month, the COP, which is chaired by Harvard Law professor Elizabeth Warren, released a report detailing the kinds of far-reaching reforms to bolster the financial regulatory system that the crisis has pointed up the need for. But Sununu and the panel's other Republican, Rep. Jeb Hensarling didn't sign on. Instead, they attached their own alternative report, that recommended an approach to financial regulation that was more friendly to Wall Street, and emphasized the need to rein in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-backed mortgage firms.

No one answered a listed number for Sen. John E. Sununu in Portsmouth, New Hampshire.

We've also contacted COP to ask whether Sununu discussed his ties to Bank of New York Mellon with panel staff. And we're hearing there's more to this story ... so we'll keep you posted.


18 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

We've all heard of crony capitalism, this is crony regulation.

Sununu must give up one or the other. I suggest he be booted off of COP, post haste.


user-pic

I suggest he be booted off, pre haste!

user-pic

eds,

agreed. This smells to the high heaven but its how Corporations and bankers protect themselves.

SSDD, Same Shit Different Day in DC.

user-pic

Some shit is worth being called what it is.

I'm writing DC on this one. His ass is grass, and I don't mean potted!

user-pic

eds,

"public service" my ass.

user-pic

K.I.S.S., please.


user-pic

What the hell was Junior thinking? He's young, has GOP pedigree & after the US attorney scandal he was the 1st Republican in Congress say Bush has to get rid of Alberto Gonzales.

Sununu's TARP gig was a golden opportunity to remake himself as a "new" sort of Republican, you know, responsible, above board, genuinely country first, etc.

Instead he's serving up more patented GOP-sell-out-voters-to-business BS. It's not like the entire world has put an electron microscope to bear on the banking industry or anything.

I always thought he was a lightweight coasting on Dad's reputation. Sununu has proved my point.

-AF
Andrew Sullivan Is A Fraud

user-pic

Although it might just be a matter of archaic language, "Board of Governnors" sounds like a rather more day-to-day role that the usual board of directors gig. But any gig whatsoever with a bank receiving TARP funds is a pretty clear conflict of interest. This is what passes for integrity among republicans these days?

user-pic

It's a great excuse to kick him off COP. I read somewhere that he's not working out all that well anyway (my impression, sorry no link).

user-pic

I used to watch BONY for investing purposes. They would come out before reporting time and imply they were going to do GREAT. Never came thru. That's been a few years back. Could've reformed. Probably not. BTW, too bad things like this aren't on the front page. Sigh.

user-pic

He needs to go. Besides "recommends" what will pump this story up?

Sununu, TARP, and Bank of New York

- An Unharmonious ConvergEX?

- A Mellon of an Idea?

user-pic

The nut doesn't fall far from the tree. If his old man was stupid enough to use a government plane to go to a rare stamp sale he is stupid enough to play both sides of this problem. Why not get paid by both sides? And have the ability to play one against the other? What a patriot!

user-pic

He could "resign" from that board, but shouldn't he be barred from participating in any conceivable government regulatory proceedings?

user-pic

I'm not sure this is relevant, but last year, at around this time, Sununu was curiously, and somewhat quietly moved from the Senate committee on banking, housing and urban affairs(right before mortgage crisis went mainstream) to the committee on finance.

http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=166x1512

user-pic

This is certainly a reason to question Sununu's ethics. It is definitely time to write to your Congressional reps and to Sen. Reid. Being on the board of ANY bank while serving on the COP is way out of line.

user-pic

Y'all can boot him anywhere you want. We booted him outta New Hampshire and don't give a damn where he's booted anymore! The guy's an egomaniac, which you'll learn about soon enough.

user-pic

A perfect example of how our ruling class works. Sununu's personal ethics and ego don't really matter. The problem is that the ties between business and government are so close, and that no one at the upper reaches of either camp appears to find this arrangement wrong. When someone is needed to make important decisions, the same network of the usual suspects is activated. Someone knew Sununu, knew he had the usual "credentials" and knew his views would be sound. No matter that he supposedly represents the interest of the country, he was one of "us" and that's all that mattered.

user-pic

USA’s FAST ECONOMIC RECOVERY IN 2 STEPS

Step 1 - STOP THE BAILOUTS and FIX THE BANKS
- Solve the loan problem.
- Solve the derivative problem.
- Reassemble whole loan mortgages

The U.S. economy is shrinking fast, because businesses cannot get loans that they need to operate normally. Banks and lenders already own $ billions in bad loans, and they are afraid to make new loans. The government gave $ billions in bailout money for banks to start lending, but banks hoard the money to save themselves.

Our financial system became untrustworthy, because it mixed $ billions in bad loans in with the good loans. Now, banks do not trust any of the loans, and the entire credit market stopped working.

The U.S. economy will continue to shrink until we untangle the loans. Once the bad loans are isolated, they can be fixed one at a time. Then trust will be restored. Credit will flow, and the economy will grow.

So far, our government is spending $ trillions on bailouts and pork projects, out of ignorance and political ideology. The real solution is much less expensive than that.

The USA has fixed this problem before, and it is not hard to fix again. This is how:

A) Start with the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC), which the federal government setup to solve a Savings and Loan problem in the 1980s.

B) RTC buys up securitized mortgages and derivatives to reassemble whole mortgage loans.
1. “Securitized mortgages” are home loans that have been bundled into large groups and sold to investors. A group of about 4,000 mortgages can be “securitized” and sold just like a stock or bond. Investors like to buy groups of mortgages because they receive all the monthly house payments.
2. Some groups of securitized mortgages were subdivided into smaller pieces, called “derivatives.” However, both of the fancy names refer to mortgage loans.
3. The problem is that many bad loans (with no payments) got mixed in with good loans. That turned the all the securitized mortgages into bad investments, which are ruining our banks. It is a huge problem, and the government has to fix it, before our economy will recover.
4. Total securitized mortgage and derivative market is estimated at $1.3 Trillion by a Professor of Economics at Ohio State University. (Also see the graph from Deutsche Bank at “The Death of Securitized Mortgages” http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2008/06/death-of-securitized-mortgages.html )
5. Government should buy up securitized mortgages and derivatives at the lowest market price, which is set via a reverse auction. (Google on “reverse auction”.)
6. Squatters, who sit on their mortgage derivatives, in order to extort big $ from the rest of the system, can be forced to sell. (Law is analogous to eminent domain, or sales forced on cybersquatters that registered the domain names of well-established companies.)
7. Government pays mortgage derivative squatters at market price set by previous reverse auctions, perhaps with a penalty to the squatters.
8. Sellers give up all rights. No new law there.
9. Banks, investors, and insurers now have cash instead of questionable mortgage loans and derivatives. So, the banking system is healthy with cash to lend.
10. Credit will flow, and the economy will grow.

C) Government reassembles whole loans from securitized mortgage components and derivatives.

D) Government sorts the newly reassembled whole loans (mortgages) into groups according to risk/quality.
1. Government uses traditional mortgage experts and guidelines to sort the home loans into quality groups, for example, a high quality group would include homeowners with 20% (or more) equity in their house at today’s market price; and house payments that are 25% (or less) of homeowners monthly income.

E) Government (RTC) sells the reassembled whole loans to traditional mortgage banks.
1. This solves the problem of renegotiating home loans with homeowners. Read on.
2. Law must be changed so that reassembled whole loan mortgages cannot be securitized into derivatives, again.
3. An important purpose is to reconnect each homeowner with his lender, and vice versa.
4. It eliminates incentive for mortgage lenders to make predatory and junk loans. If the loan fails, the lender is stuck with a bad loan.
5. Government recovers much of the $1.3 Trillion purchase cost, because government auctions off the reassembled mortgages.
6. The lower quality, more risky mortgages would fetch a lower price at auction.
7. Mortgage companies, that buy the risky loans, will have more room to negotiate with the homeowners.
8. Some homeowner negotiations will not succeed. Those homeowners will move into affordable rentals. (The government does not owe everyone a free house.)
9. Other renters would like to buy those empty homes at reduced market prices.
10. If the government gets stuck with some homes, the government could profit by selling the homes when the housing market recovers.

F) Insurers like AIG may be reorganized through bankruptcy.
1. Securitized mortgage pools never made business sense, unless they were protected by various insurance schemes.
2. Those insurance schemes always were a scam.
3. Insurance only works when most of the insured assets are never hit with a disaster. That is why flood insurance does not work very well. A major flood ruins all the buildings in a large area, all at the same time. So, the insurance company goes broke, and people that bought the insurance are not protected. That is the problem with securitized mortgage insurance. In an economic downturn, the “disaster” hits all the houses at the same time. Securitized mortgage insurance was doomed to fail, and the insurance companies went broke in 2009.
4. Companies that ran the insurance scam may have to go through bankruptcy.
5. Never ending government bailouts for insurers like AIG are just throwing good money after bad. So, stop the bailouts.

This plan is inexpensive, tried and true. It leaves the banks healthy, with cash to lend. It restores trust in the credit markets, so loans will be made. It reassembles mortgage derivatives into whole loans, and restarts traditional mortgage lending. People can get loans to buy homes. Credit will flow, and the economy will grow.*


Step 2 – STOP THE PORK and START THE RECOVERY

*The economy will grow if President Obama’s massive tax, borrow, and spending plans can be stopped, before he creates another Great Depression. Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt already tried to tax, borrow and spend their way out of a recession in the 1930s. Instead, they created the Great Depression, which lasted 12 years. Straight as he goes, President Obama is doing it, again. Nevertheless, cleaning up the securitized mortgage mess is a necessary first step.

If President Obama announced Steps 1 and 2, today, the stock market would go up within hours. Investors love a real business plan, instead of a political pork plan. Millions of people will be wealthier, feel wealthier, and have more money to spend. That will jump start the economic recovery within days.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Tag Cloud



Subscribe to this blog's feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address