TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Lobby Firm Sent Forged Climate Change Letter To Congressman

OK, this is a good one...

Via The American Prospect: Freshman Democratic congressman Tom Perriello -- whose Virginia district leans Republican -- faced a tough decision last month over whether to support the climate change bill. As he was weighing the issue, he got a letter from a non-profit group in his district that focuses on issues of importance to Hispanics. The letter urged Perriello to oppose the bill because it could raise low-income members' utility bills. "Many of our members are on tight budgets and the sizes of their monthly utility bills are important expense items," it read in part.

But, reports the Charlottesville Daily Progress, the letter was a fake:

"They stole our name. They stole our logo. They created a position title and made up the name of someone to fill it. They forged a letter and sent it to our congressman without our authorization," said Tim Freilich, who sits on the executive committee of Creciendo Juntos, a nonprofit network that tackles issues related to Charlottesville's Hispanic community. "It's this type of activity that undermines Americans' faith in democracy."

The faked letter from Creciendo Juntos was signed by "Marisse K. Acevado, Asst Member Coordinator," an identity and position at Creciendo Juntos that do not exist.

The letter -- subsequently obtained by TPMmuckraker -- had actually been sent by someone at the D.C. lobbying firm Bonner and Associates -- a pioneer in "strategic grassroots/grasstops" lobbying whose clients have included Citicorp, Aetna, PhRMA, Dow Chemical, AT&T, and General Motors, among others.

And Perriello staffers soon dug out five other forged letters -- also obtained by TPMmuckraker -- urging the congressman to oppose the bill -- all purportedly from the local branch of the NAACP, whose president says he's "appalled" at the scam.

The paper adds:

The fake NAACP letters were faxed to Perriello's office from the Arlington headquarters of a company called Professional Risk Management Services Inc. A representative of the company said she had no knowledge of why the fax would have been sent from her office, adding that at least 60 employees have access to the fax machine.

But here's maybe the most infuriating thing. Bonner still isn't coming close to clean about the incident.

A partner with the firm traveled to Charlottesville to apologize to Creciendo Juntos' chairwoman, and has told the group that it has fired the employee who wrote it. But it hasn't said who hired it to work on the climate change bill -- and it doesn't have to disclose the information because it doesn't do direct lobbying of Congress. Bonner and Associates didn't return calls from the Daily Progress. Nor did it immediately return TPMmuckraker's.

This isn't the first time that they've been caught out blurring the lines between "strategic grassroots" lobbying and outright deception. As the Daily Progress notes:

The AARP Bulletin reported in 2006 that the "60 Plus Association" hired Bonner & Associates in 2003 to manage what it called an "Astroturf" campaign against prescription drug legislation in Minnesota and New Mexico, meaning that it was an artificial version of a grassroots campaign.

Bonner & Associates hired callers to identify themselves as members of the 60 Plus Association and urge residents to ask their governors to veto the legislation. Pharmaceutical company Pfizer later admitted that it had paid Bonner & Associates to undertake the campaign, AARP reported.

And it engineered a similar scheme in Maryland. When it was revealed that a letter opposing an effort to lower the cost of prescription drugs actually came from Bonner and Associates, rather than a group of African-American charities, Bonner told a reporter: "It's a great exercise in the First Amendment."

It's worth noting that despite the letter to Periello, the climate change bill passed the House -- with Perriello's support.

Something tells us Periello wasn't the only wavering Democrat who got that fake letter. And there's more to this story that's going to get shaken loose sooner or later...

Additional reporting by Brian Beutler.

Late Update: Bonner responds.

Later Update: Rep. Ed Markey announces an investigation into the letters.


38 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Gee, that's not a felony false statement offense under 18 USC 1001(a)(3) or anything.

user-pic

I'm neither a lawyer nor law enforcement officer, but this also smacks of mail fraud.

user-pic

Yeah but when you get great news like this nearly every day, nothing's illegal. I wonder if it's too late to release another rap video about health care??

user-pic

Sorry, but I read subsection Cc) of that USC cite, which says that this doesn't apply if it's in the legislature's domain and the document wasn't required by the legislature.

Kind of 'you can't lie to us when we ASK you a question, but you can lie to us the rest of the time.'

user-pic

Creciendo Juntos needs to sue the pants off those low-lifes at the astro-turf firm, find out who they were working for, and sue the pants off them too.

user-pic

Is Rep. Perriello guilty of something? That image juxtaposed with that headline sort of imply such.

user-pic

What?

"and it doesn't have to disclose the information because it doesn't do direct lobbying of Congress."

So if I commit fraud, I don't have to account for the particulars as long as I don't lobby congress?
Deeply squirrelly notion.

user-pic

Um, how is mailing or faxing a letter advocating a particular position, to a Congressman's office, NOT lobbying Congress directly?

Can somebody 'splain that to me?

user-pic

"It's a great exercise in the First Amendment."

That will be my defense next time I get caught selling fake lottery tickets.

user-pic

Maybe I can use this defense in my next counterfeiting scheme:

I consider these little green fake bills to be an expression of what I believe in. Cold. Hard. Fake. Cash. To deny my write to create and spend these pieces of paper infringes upon my rights under the Constitution of the United States.

Yeah right. I don't think that my idea above has any merit. Nor does this lobbying firm's lame defensive statements have merit.

user-pic

lol, to deny my "right" not "write".

user-pic

Disgusting! These corporations have purchased our government! I pray that there are good people in politics who would rather serve a single term and change this nation for the better than to do nothing again and again while raking in huge amounts of cash from corporate interests.

The mid western blue dogs who can't raise big money within their states are getting huge payments from outside interest groups because a vote in the senate is a vote in the senate no mater what the population of your state is and it's easier to buy the allegiance of Dem from Montana who needs campaign money just to survive than it is to actually fight the merits of something like health care reform.

user-pic

"Creciendo Juntos needs to sue the pants off those low-lifes at the astro-turf firm, find out who they were working for, and sue the pants off them too."

I'm sure part of Bonner's process in choosing them was based on their inability to fund such legal action if the ruse were to be discovered.

user-pic

Kinda hard to believe that's the case with the NAACP, though.

user-pic

Looks like the corporations (or their lobbyists) have no shame, they will do any thing, use any dishonest tactic..(skewing polls?) any lie to protect the status quo and keep legislation in their favor and the money rolling in....they don't seem to care one little bit about the country or the people who live here...and these are the people that the Republicans and unfortunately quite a few "moderate" Democrats side with (for money of course!)....they want the Health of people to stay in the hands of the Health Care Corporations.. (and half the country is backing them! has to be pure unadulterated ignorance of facts) disgraceful! As I have said its not about right vs left, conservatives vs liberals...its going to take all of us, fighting to take our country back from the greedy stranglehold the corporations have on this country and its people...In ever crisis this country faces..financial, Health Care, climate, even the "wars" some greedy bastard in a Corporation is misinforming, manipulating and lobbying information to keep things just the way they are....

user-pic

"Looks like the corporations (or their lobbyists) have no shame, they will do any thing, use any dishonest tactic..(skewing polls?) any lie to protect the status quo and keep legislation in their favor and the money rolling in."

Uh, yeah . . . that's what the Free Market looks like. To Free Marketers, it's all business, and anything that can be bought and sold should be. Use any financial tactic whatsoever to buy the influence in government, then use that influence to make everything you did to get there legal. It's just sound business practice, attempting to change the landscape of government from democracy to plutocracy, and I have no doubt there is a significant portion of the wealthy population who looks on democracy as a quaint idea that is past its prime. They are, in effect, attempting a long, slow coup by spending.

user-pic

Hmm, wonder how many letters they are sending about the Healthcare debate. And who the letters are supposedly from.

user-pic

Does this mean I can send letters on stationary that looks like it's from the Heritage Foundation or AEI?

I could have some fun with that ...

user-pic

Sorry - that should read "Heritaeg Foundation" and "American Entreprise Institute".

user-pic

Great reporting. Seriously, TPM continues to make the corporate news outlets look more and more like ... well, like blogs used to look. TPM is practicing the journalism our Founding Fathers had in mind when they enshrined the press in our Bill of Rights.

Isn't that crazy? It used to be that the web was your source for poorly-researched, anonymously-sourced gossip, while the print media gave you conscientious, in-depth journalism... and now it's the other way around.

The New York Times: All the Spin We're Told To Print!

user-pic

Interestingly, there are only six related news articles listed in Google at the moment, two of the blogs (one of which is the WSJ!).

user-pic

Isn't the idea that they don't directly lobby congress somewhat undermined by the fact that they were directly lobbying a congressman. And fraudulently to boot? In a way aren't they claiming that if they were being honest, sure they'd have to face scrutiny, but since they're lying about what they do, they can't be touched?

Ah Washington.

user-pic

Charges will be filed, right? The freshman Congress should now know he needs to vote for the bill.

user-pic

He already did.

user-pic

and this has been going on for how long?
anyone care to guess??

and how many other scams are ongoing?

a good time to push for a ban on all corporate lobbying of the congress.

user-pic

The explanation is, the lobbying disclosure regulations differentiate between "grassroots" lobbying and "direct" lobbying (i.e., going in to see a congressperson or making a call on behalf of a client). That's to preserve the ability of everyone, no matter who they are or what their purpose is, to contact members of Congress by mail or phone, or to ask others to contact them, without being subject to disclosure rules. Otherwise, every ordinary Joe or non-profit group who spent a large amount of time signing petitions, making calls, sending letters, etc. would be required to register as a lobbyist and fill out disclosure forms. It's a loophole when it comes to situations like this, yes, but it's there to keep ordinary citizens free from the requirements.

Having said that, what they did is against the law and they should be prosecuted. And I certianly hope this leads to a greater scrutiny of all the stuff that pours in to congressional offices. I would bet a surprising and damning amount of the "grassroots" calls and leters they receive are actually coordinated by corporate/conservative groups.

user-pic

One last point - Republicans have been making great hay out of the energy vote, and claiming there will be a "populist uprising" against the Dems who voted for the bill. It would be a good idea to bring this situation up every time one of them starts mouthing off about that....

user-pic

i think its brilliant and i think i can make this work for me.

i am going to send letters on the NAMBLA letterhead to churches all over with my local republican congress critter's name on them. what are they going to do, sue me?

prove that this guy is NOT in NAMBLA. best of luck.

user-pic

It should be noted that Perriello is an impressive guy (and not just because he turned a tough district blue). From his bio:

After receiving his law degree from Yale University, Tom accepted an assignment working to end atrocities in the West African countries of Liberia and Sierra Leone, which had suffered long civil wars fueled by blood diamonds. Tom’s work with child soldiers, amputees, and local pro-democracy groups in Sierra Leone played a significant role in the peace and reconciliation process that ended twelve years of violence in that country.

Tom then became Special Advisor and spokesperson for the International Prosecutor during the showdown that forced Liberian dictator Charles Taylor from power without firing a shot. After this success, Tom served as a national security analyst for the Century Foundation. He has worked inside Darfur and twice in Afghanistan.
Changing the American Debate on Faith in Politics

Since 2004, Tom has helped to launch a political and social movement in this country that is credited with shifting the national debate about America’s moral priorities. He helped found FaithfulAmerica.org and Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, which bring together faith communities to fight for children’s health care, supporting a higher minimum wage, environmental stewardship, and responsible solutions in Iraq. Inspired by the prophetic vision of Dr. King, Wilberforce, and Micah, Tom believes that America must reverse the erosion of our commitment to the common good and restore our understanding that our nation rises or falls together.

user-pic

Good old Jack Bonner. He use to be top political aide to Sen. Heinz. Yep, just another Republican, so finding a little scam here or there and coupled with a bunch of lies is not surprising.

user-pic

SUE THEM! SUE THEM INTO THE FUCKING GROUND!

user-pic

I agree, sue them for so much that they go bankrupt!

user-pic

Re-pug-li-cant's are nothing but lying thieves.
The people who sent this forged letter should be sued.
Could the organization sue them for using their name under false pretences?

user-pic

I got a letter from the NRA saying they support restrictions on gun ownership ... What?? Well, it's what I want to believe anyway, so why should I question it...?

user-pic

Why isn't Holder investigating?

His office has a lot more clout to smack Bonner upside the head than a limp congressional investigation will.

user-pic

Hay may I remind you dudes that this is politics at its highes level.
Its not like someone is trying to buy a Senate seat or
sending a little girl to a public meeting on health care and mommy was a local financal officer of old stupidly's campaign.
Oh yea, some of you have a lot to learn about the non profit lieablity resposableity when it come to proof of docs..

user-pic

Nice post.Looking forward to reading more from you


seo company

user-pic

The fight over impending climate-change legislation in Congress appears to be getting dirtier. A Washington, D.C.-based lobbyist forged five letters purportedly from minority groups and sent them to Virginia freshman Congressman.


Online Sweepstakes

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address