TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

McKalip: I'm No Racist -- I Once Had A Career Counseling Day For Black Kids

More McKalip fallout:

The Florida Medical Association yesterday condemned McKalip's racist email and called on him to apologize to the president:

STATEMENT ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE FLORIDA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (July 23, 2009) - The Florida Medical Association is an organization with a zero-tolerance for racist or discriminatory behavior. As such, we do not condone the circulation of what has been described by the press as a racist depiction of President Obama by David McKalip, MD. Dr. McKalip's actions do not in anyway reflect the positions, attitudes or culture of the Florida Medical Association.

The Florida Medical Association finds the actions by Dr. McKalip to be hurtful and in poor judgment. Further, we find his actions disrespectful to President Obama and the Office of the President. The Florida Medical Association is disappointed by Dr. McKalip's actions and urges Dr. McKalip to extend President Obama an apology for this egregious deed.

McKalip did indeed apologize.

But that may not be the end of it. A Florida Democratic lawmaker has called on McKalip to resign as president-elect of the Pinellas County Medical Association and as a board member of the Florida Medical Association. State Rep. Darryl Rouson called the email "absolutely terrible" and an "outrageous act."

And it's worth noting that McKalip's original response to the flap was much more defiant than his subsequent apology. In an interview yesterday with the St. Petersburg Times, which picked up the story, he declared: "I am not a racist. I am simply a person speaking up to make sure patients don't get hurt by the government and by insurance companies.''

And he claimed that he was being targeted solely because of his political opposition to health-care reform. "Because I've been so effective in pointing out how the government plans are going to hurt patients in very serious ways ... the only way they can neutralize my message is to discredit me personally," he said.

As a defense against the racism charge, he noted, in the paper's words, that he had "helped organize a career counseling day several years ago for African-American Boy Scouts." And he blamed liberal activists for touting the email, which he called a "satire."

Later in the day, though, he shifted strategy, and offered a "sincere apology."

Late Update: More in the McKalip apology saga. Along with his "sincere apology," McKalip sent the following email to his Tea Party listserv, minimizing the witch doctor email merely as a "lapse in judgment" and blaming the controversy on "powerful enemies" who were "try[ing] to discredit me because they can't discredit my arguments."

Here's the full message:

I have had a very hard day. When you stand up and fight effectively for freedom and to protect the rights of patients from control by the government and insurance companies - you develop powerful enemies. They have used the opportunity of a lapse in judgment to try to discredit me since they can't discredit my arguments. I am proud of my accomplishments in this fight. I am more proud of the hundreds of thousands of Americans I have come to know who feel as I do and are willing to stand up for freedom. The next few days will be difficult, and I ask for your support.

This message, and the interview McKalip gave to the St. Petersburg Times noted above, suggest that, at the least, his P.R.-aided contrition wasn't the full story.


20 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Nixon met with Sammy Davis Junior, but he still hated blacks, and considered abortion to be okay only if it was a mixed-race baby.

user-pic

I assume the Florida Medical Association has African-American doctors in their membership. They probably don't appreciate the "satire" quite as much.

user-pic

Funny how they seem to get apologetic, when it starts to affect their wallet!

user-pic

Some of my best friends are...witchdoctors? No, wait....

user-pic

Just found this gem of the brain doctor speaking to a yacht club tea party (seriously). In full white-coat regalia, he blames the Obama administration for “concocting a crisis” in health care, calls Medicare “the greatest Ponzi scheme ever created short of Social Security.”

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwJRdp73EEI

Disgusting.

user-pic

Great clip. I love it when he mentions Glenn Beck and everyone shouts out their support!

user-pic

Mod parent up--I love the imagery of having a teabagging party on a yacht. Ronald Reagan's father-in-law would be so proud!

user-pic

The man is in Florida and he condemns Medicare and Social Security?? Things that Florida residents depend on to a greater extent, I would guess, than in any other state of the nation? I'd sure like to seem him try that when he's not on that yacht. He'd be attacked with canes and walkers!!

user-pic

Haven't we suspected that racism was at the heart of much of the opposition to Obama's plans and policies? Well, here you go........

user-pic

Gee, I wonder what careers, those "black boys" got counseled to pursue. Gardeners? Newspaper deliverers? Cleaners? Hospital Orderlies? I'm sure he was very helpful to them.

user-pic

My favorite quote from this idiot:

His opponents "try to discredit me since they can't discredit my arguments"

stunning lack of irony there

user-pic

Well.. right. The guy is an idiot on health care, but instead of attacking his arguments, everyone's yelling that he's a racist based on one thing -- he liked a photo that made a point on Obama's health plan by showing Obama as an indonesian witch doctor. I'm having trouble deciding where the real ignorance lies.

user-pic

Well, at least he didn't say he used to schtupp black boy scouts. Okay, okay, that was rude...So shoot me. It's being reported about some Mormon Scout Leaders is all I'm sayin'.

user-pic

What's McKalip Worried About?

The Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care says that there are 1.58 neurosurgeons per 100,000 residents in St. Petersberg (all sucking in socialized Medicare $$$$), In Minneapolis, there are .85 neurosurgeons per 100,000. And they're much better off.

The Dartmouth research shows that back surgery is highly dependent on the... wait for it... number of neurosurgeons and is unrelated to the actual needs of the population.

user-pic

I AM NOT A RACIST! Why some of my best friends are kikes, spics and darkies.

user-pic

If it was really just satire, he could have shown Obama as a medicine show pitchman, or a medieval doctor performing bloodletting. He just never thoguht this e-mail would get outside the conservative bubble, or maybe he forgets there's a world outside the bubble.

user-pic

He may have if he'd created the image, but he didn't.

This torch-wielding-mob thing is getting a little old. Go to freerepublic and you'll find countless people there mocking Obama with "ebonics" or ugly racial imagery. This guy's crime was to think an image insulting Obama's health care plan was funny. Sure he may have liked the racial aspect but it may not have occurred to him. No one knows what's in his head, yet people are screaming for him to resign from whatever positions their Google searches turn up.

It's pretty ugly.

user-pic

Please.

It may not have occurred to him? Really? Do you really believe that? When you saw the picture, did you not immediately realize that there was a "racial aspect" to the image? That is the only aspect that is immediately apparent. If there is an aspect that relates to health care, it's a lot more subtle than the racial one. I don't know that the original even is an image of a "witchdoctor" or "shaman" or anything related to medicine and, if it is, I really doubt the doctor would know that from looking at it.

Your claim that he might not have noticed it was racist is like the congressman from Alabama who called Obama "uppity" in an interview and then added, "Yes, I said uppity," but when later confronted said it had never occurred to him that "uppity" had a racial connotation. You/he can claim that, but it's not at all credible.

He didn't just email this to his best friend; he emailled it to a public google listserv. The AMA has standards of ethical conduct and he failed to meet them. All of those positions he's resigning from are ones where he was representing a group or a position. Very few groups would want to be represented by someone who displayed open racism in a public forum. As he said himself, "someone in my position should have known better."

And the reason no one is bothering to debate his stupid ideas is because no one knew who he was until he did this collosally stupid thing.

user-pic

this is hardly the most outrageous example of racism i've ever seen.

i'm not even sure it's all that racist.

obama is black. taking heed of that fact is not racist.

imagine if the ad had been a picture of bush's face super-imposed over that of a snake-handling hillbilly faith healer advocating abstinence only and outlawing abortions.

perfectly appropriate.

it was my impression that the point of the above ad is to make the argument that obama's plan is not good science, not well grounded in reason and will be ineffective. that's hardly a racist argument.

it's wrong on the facts, it's not funny, but i wouldn't say its particularly racist.

user-pic

Great post.

I've been offering on-the-ground, running commentary on this situation at saintpetersblog1.blogspot.com

Just compiled the list of McKalip's contributions to Florida politicians:

http://saintpetersblog1.blogspot.com/2009/07/david-mckalips-long-list-of.html

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Tag Cloud



Subscribe to this blog's feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address