TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

Only Three Palin Ethics Complaints Were Still Pending

If you had to pick out a coherent explanation given by Sarah Palin for her decision to quit as Alaska governor, you'd probably have to settle on the notion that she felt her agenda was being paralyzed by frivolous ethics complaints, and that she only foresaw additional ones. So she stepped down so as not to continue to drag Alaskans through the process.

"Palin Says Ethics Complaints Were Paralyzing" reported the Anchorage Daily News after the governor's round of beachside interviews Monday. And Lieutenant Governor Sean Parnell, who'll soon replace Palin as governor, had given that line over the weekend, saying on Fox News that Palin had talked to him about the toll the complaints had taken.

Obviously, the ethics complaint excuse doesn't make sense for a lot of reasons. Still, it's worth taking a close look at the list of 18 complaints filed against Palin during her tenure as governor, as compiled by the ADN.

The roundup offers a useful resource for anyone who was having trouble keeping the various Pain scandals and mini-scandals straight. But it also makes clear that, for all Palin's concern about dragging Alaskans through a traumatic process, only three of the complaints were still pending.

What are they? Here's the paper's description:

Jan. 26: Two complaints filed by McLeod alleged two of Palin's top aides misused their official positions for Palin's personal and political gain. The complaints said then-press secretary Bill McAllister and Kris Perry -- director of the governor's Anchorage office -- worked on state time to benefit Palin's interests during and after her vice presidential quest.

...

April 27: Contends Palin is misusing the governor's office for personal gain by securing unwarranted benefits and receiving improper gifts through the Alaska Fund Trust. The fund was recently established by supporters to help Palin pay off more than $500,000 in legal debts stemming from other ethics complaints, including troopergate. Complaint filed by Eagle River resident, Kim Chatman.

Aside from those, everything's been dealt with, in most cases by the state personnel board, which handles such matters. (Since Palin, as governor, has the power to fire the personnel board's members, the independence of its judgments is hardly beyond reproach -- but that's a whole other story.) And most of the more frivolous complaints seem to have been dismissed pretty promptly. As for the three that are pending, for a woman who weathered Trooper-Gate, it's hard to see how any of these could tip her over the edge.

Of course, Palin seems to be claiming that, because her enemies are so unscrupulous, there would no doubt have been more complaints soon. And maybe there would have been. But it seems likely that any future frivolous charges would have been dealt with as quickly as those in the past.

The notion that this barrage of complaints was preventing her from doing her job just doesn't seem to hold up.


25 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

There was a reporter on NPR on Fresh Air last night (7/7) talking about covering Palin and he was fascinating.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=106322053

Rachel Maddow was also great saying so let's get this straight--Palin wants to be known as someone who objects to ethics?

I think there is more underway and worse than state ethics stuff. Which is why she left.

user-pic

i hope you are correct. I want this woman to go down in flames. I am sick to death of hearing about her and the media's fricking obsession with her.

user-pic

Didn't you just love Rachel standing there in her waders last night. It was really funny since she actually was fishing last week on her vacation.

I love Rachel

user-pic

But they walk with God. Obviously a Maverick would resign in the middle of her job to go and fight the evildoers.

user-pic

I highly recommend listening to the NPR interview.

I especially enjoyed the part where Terry Gross asks what Gov. Palin's accomplishments are/were while in office.

Other than being able to see Alaska from her house and being the biggest Alaskan celebrity since Jewel, there wasn't much.

user-pic

I just have this feeling that she knows something really big is about to hit the fan, that's why she resigned.

I don't think she gives a crap about her family or her state. If she did, she would have governed more ethically and effectively and not parade her family in public.

But again, she's a maverick man.

user-pic

Another ethics complaint was filed on Monday of this week by Zane Henning "for continuing to collect per diem expenses from the State of Alaska while still living in, and commuting from her own home". This is from the Mudflats web site.

user-pic

Guess she has a pretty good "Department of Law" up there in Alaska.

user-pic

Actually, the "Department of Law" is the proper name for the justice department in Alaska. http://www.law.state.ak.us/

Your snark would be much more effective if you knew what you were talking about.

Now you end up appearing, accurately, as less informed than Sarah Palin. Horrors!

user-pic

she is an empty headed control freak...has gotten by on her looks until someone had the audacity to question her intellect and suitability for the second highest office in the land....even then she was to damn lazy to actually try to learn or think of the real issues...now her "ethics" are being questioned..how dare you?...how dare any one question the Beautiful Queen of Hearts and her "soap box opera, white trailer trash" tactics...after all she is the Governor..and when the Governor of Alaska does it..that means its legal!...(If not..If I have to follow the laws and actually do my job, instead of just looking good and babbling like an uneducated fool in front of the cameras then I'll show you ALL..!!!I'll just quit!!!)

user-pic

I sort of take her at her word. 3 pending ethics complains is not exactly a small number? I do agree with all the negative commentary on her but....her own explanation is not exactly flattering. If she would falsify something it likely would at least sound good.

user-pic

Watch her visits to the lower 48 during the next six months...I think she has some big money backing down here. How many of the 2006 contenders from both parties ran without authoring a book? She fixin' to start one, soon. The nut cases are looking for a leader and she fits like glove. A lot of independents would swing for her.

user-pic
A lot of independents would swing for her.

no. they wouldn't.

that is a wishful-thinking storyline that her fans and enablers have been pushing despite the mountain of evidence to the contrary.

user-pic

She has a manipulative personality. As long as she gets what she wants, she wins. That's it!

Her thing about the "family voting" was a perfect example. The way she stated the question to her children was completely loaded. What Palin child would say, "Um, Mom, I really really really just want to to stay home with all 7 of us."

Yeah, right! As if a dissenting vote would not be considered treason in the Palin family. Even Todd is afraid of her. Beware of manipulative people of either sex -- they operate under a different system than the rest of us, and therefore we are susceptible to their deceptions. Most of us just can't fathom the total bullshit they are capable of.

user-pic

SILLY Sarah Failin'.

user-pic

I think everyone is digging too deep and missing the obvious, pervasive lie that has never been addressed.

She suddenly resigns, surrounded by family, but does not actually quit (which she'd have to do if an outside force like an investigation or indictment were coming.) Instead she quickly lays out her own timeframe for quitting.

I think this is Bristol/Trig coming home to roost. So what if Bristol is tired of being pretend sister, and getting hauled all over the country because Sarah isn't raising her special needs kid the way she needs to? What if Bristol finally demanded to live her own life, and said, "enough is enough. Quit this crap or I am telling the world about the fakery. And I still have pictures and medical records!" So she decides to announce that she won't run for re-election, thinking it satisfies Bristol, but Bristol knows that another 18 months of public spotlight won't help her son (TRIG), so she doesn't play along. Quit or it all comes out.

Krep. Hasty, scattered presser; no one knows or understands. She can't explain cuz it will reveal a HUGE lie that no one will forgive, even in the community, much less politics. So she just rambles, but really explains nothing. Then goes fishing with Hubby (who was gone fishing, not getting ready for gov-quitting), but without Trig.

Only thing that fully makes sense at this point. Bristol is tired of the lies and wants her life back.

user-pic

So you're saying that Bristol had TWO kids in less than TWO years, and that her boyfriend, who is completely estranged is keeping it quiet?

I think you are mistaken.

user-pic

I have to half agree with Prof. Fish (NYT) on this one: Palin didn't know what she was getting herself into. This "only two complaints pending" claim is wholly disingenuous. Eighteen complaints, most of which appear to be somewhere between petty and false, is something that would drive most people out of a job.

The other half, however, is that by agreeing to be McCain's VP running mate she opened herself up to close examination. Moreover, given the lies, distortions and demagogy she engaged in during the election, she has little reason to complain.

user-pic

Also, it may have been mentioned in the NPR interview (or elsewhere), but I understand that:

1. The cost of the ethics complaints were around $268,000 to the state not nearly the $2 million Palin claims.

2. The most costly complaint was the one involving her former brother-in-law, Trooper Wooten, and that complaint was resolved prior to her return to Alaska after the election.

3. She filed one of the complaints herself in an attempt to move the Wooten proceedings to a board she had control over.

4. As the NPR interview more than implied, many of these complaints could have been resolved by a letter from the Governor and did not necessitate a personal attorney.

user-pic

5. In addition, I believe only one of the complaints was filed from someone on the national scene and that was the complaint about the $150,000 worth of clothes she received from the RNC.

Interesting, each Palin lie contains 1% truth and 99% BS.

user-pic

I am an Independent and I certainly would not "swing for her"!

She is an insult to hardworking, intelligent women everywhere. She is nothing more than a caricature of herself, a manipulative nutcase and a joke.

She has no integrity or dignity.

Follow the money and you'll soon see the real reasons for her resignation.

user-pic

RECENT POLLING DATA SHOWS THE POLITICAL RELEVANCE OF SARAH PALIN'S CELEBRITY - IT'S BAD NEWS FOR THOSE REPUBLICANS WHO DESPERATELY BELIEVE SHE'S THERE BEST CHANCE FOR DEFEATING OBAMA IN 2012

"Yet another poll shows that Sarah Palin is simultaneously the best and worst that the GOP has to offer. Data from a new Rasmussen Poll (July 6, 750 likely GOP voters, +/- 4%):

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/national_news/national_survey_toplines/july_2009/gop_july_6_2009

So Sarah Palin is that she's virtually tied with Mitt Romney on top the GOP's 2012 field...but the bad news is that while Mitt Romney is the least favorite among just 9% of Republicans, Palin is the least favorite among a whopping 21%.

Palin's "least favorite" numbers are six points worse than Newt Gingrich's, and unlike Haley Barbour (with whom she is tied), Republicans actually know who she is and consider her a likely contender for the nomination.

The good news for Republicans is that Palin's negatives will make it very difficult for her to win their nomination. The consolation prize for Democrats is that her numbers are strong enough that she just might give it a try."

user-pic

I'm supposing that by giving it "a try" you are NOT yet imagining a campaign. She could not run for office without speaking incoherently. More likely she is running from office.

Was she on the taxpayers'dime for those 'I can't predict the next fish-run' interviews?

user-pic

Every since the election I kept hoping she would just go back to Alaska - but she just kept showing up all over the place - I would yell at the TV "the election is over - go home". I think (after reading about her ego etc.) that she enjoyed the limelight and adoration so much that she can't go back. She was plucked from obscurity, given a new wardrobe, flown all over the country to adoring crowds. She can't bear to go back to obscurity-The office in Alaska doing budgets, boring meetings, etc.

And yes, she is also cashing in. If she waited until the end of her term, there might not be the demand anymore for some obscure governor from Alaska. She was turning into a joke (she blames the press). There was no serious presidential run in her future. Hopefully in two years no one will care what she has to say.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Tag Cloud



Subscribe to this blog's feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address