TPM Muckraker

« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

U.S. Soldier Captured In Afghanistan: What Happened?

We've told you recently about Ralph Peters, the Fox News analyst who accused a U.S. soldier, captured in Afghanistan, of deserting his buddies. Peters, a retired U.S. Army officer, said said the Taliban could save the U.S. "a lot of legal hassle" by executing the soldier.

But Peters' heartlessness and stupidity aside, the underlying story of the captured soldier, Bowe Bergdahl, is worth a closer look too -- especially because the Pentagon so far hasn't given a clear story about just how Bergdahl ended up in enemy hands.

Let's take a look at what's been reported so far:

On July 2nd, the AP reported that, according to two anonymous U.S. officials, the military had intercepted communications between insurgents saying they had captured an American in eastern Afghanistan near the Pakistan border. A defense official told AP that a soldier had been noticed missing during a routine check of his unit a few days previously.

But the anonymous defense sources added some other curious information. They said his body armor and weapon were found on the base. And, in keeping with that, one source said initial reports suggested he was off duty at the time he went missing, having just completed a shift. Both sources said the soldier "just walked off" the base, with three Afghans, after he finished working, adding they had no explanation for why.

It was information like this -- true or not -- that seemed to prompt Peters' despicable performance on Fox.

Since then, more claims have come out. In a video posted by his captors last week, in which he gives the date as July 14, Bergdahl says he was captured as he lagged behind while on a patrol. (Of course, Bergdahl was likely saying whatever his captors wanted him to -- he also says US troops are suffering from low morale and should be brought back to the U.S. "where we belong" -- so it's hard to know how much stock to put in that.)

Then on Monday, ABC News reported that, according to an unnamed senior Afghan army official, Bergdahl had been taken from a village near his base. The Afghan official said that the captors "punched and hit the soldier after some resistance. But than they were able to take the soldier and left all of his things: weapon, body armored and radios." The official said the operation had been carried out by men working with Mullah Sangeen, a top Afghan insurgent commander, and that Bergdahl may since have been moved to Pakistan.

And two Taliban spokesmen have said that their group was not involved in the kidnapping, and suggested that Sangeen was working with Siraj Haqqani, another insurgent who is believed to be responsible for the capture last year of New York Times reporter David Rohde.

CNN reported today that Sangeen had suggested in an interview that Bergdahl would be killed unless U.S. forces stopped targeting civilians. Sangeen also claimed that Bergdahl had gotten drunk while visiting a military post, and had been ambushed while returning to his car -- a charge that a U.S. military source denied. Military sources also told CNN that they believe Bergdahl is still in Afghanistan.

And -- for whatever this is worth -- Peters went back on Fox News last night, where he said he'd been told by a "very senior military leader" that Bergdahl had indeed deserted. "He left his weapon of his own volition," said Peters.

In that appearance, Peters also called Bergdahl a "nut" and suggested he's "mentally disturbed." In making those slurs, Peters may have had in mind recent news reports that suggest Bergdahl -- an Idaho native who rode a bike, has learned ballet and worked as a barista in a coffee shop -- doesn't fit the Fox News profile of a culturally conservative grunt. But speculating on the what's going on in Ralph Peters's head seems like a dangerous game.

We've still seen nothing on the record from the Pentagon, which didn't respond to a call from TPMmuckraker. The military is often loath to say much publicly in cases like this, for fear of jeopardizing efforts to secure the soldier's release. But we'll keep you posted as more solid facts come out.


21 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I suppose the next we know is a combined Bither and Tea Bagger hit squad will be set to Pakistan and deal with this "known deserter" and kook. I'm sure Peters would be glad to lead the squad.

user-pic

The way Peters and O'Reilly discussed this serviceman who is in Taliban custody was disgusting. Peters calling for the Taliban to go ahead and execute him in order to save the military the time and expense of a trial is way beyond the bounds of reasonable opinion.

Bergdahl's family should file a lawsuit against FuxNews for their willing participation in escaling this hate speech against a US serviceman on active duty!

Whatever happened to "support the troops"? Or was that yellow car magnet supposed to be enough?

PEACE

user-pic

Right you are, but nothing that the far right wing says can be trusted. Of course Shaun sweetie and all the other Fox celebrities have never signed up for any war so they really understand all about this guy and his problems. Until they know the facts, we will never expect them to shut their mouths. You know, they bleat over and over about supporting the troops but you see just how much their wobbly support means when times get tough. I prefer to wait and hear all his story straight from the guys mouth when we get him out of there. Till then, shut up Shaun and BillO and you other guys. We are sick of the lack of military support you guys show. Just fine weather friends who sit on their fannies here and blab about someone who actually went to war. Did either of you do it? I thought not!!!!!

user-pic

So, according to Fox News military analyst Ralph Peters, Pfc. James Gonzalez, another missing soldier, should be executed by his Mexican captors to save the U.S. "a lot of legal hassle". You know, how you do when you have American soldiers missing from duty under unclear circumstances--disparage them and then abandon them to the enemy.

user-pic

What? That changes everything. He rode a bike to get around town. Obviously he doesn't love the USA, otherwise he would have had hisself a fine 'merican made Chevy pickup truck.

user-pic

Bergdahl has learned ballet and worked as a barista in a coffee shop? C'mon -- Peters thinks Bergdahl's gay, that's why he's all worked up about this and doesn't care if they kill him.

user-pic

I wonder what Peters had to say when John McCain made his propaganda videos for the North Vietnamese?

user-pic

You know, that was my first thought when I saw Peters' original appearance. McCain is the first to admit what he did and acknowledge it was a consequence of being tortured (which is why his fight against US torture practices lasted as long as it did, finally defeated only by campaign pragmatics I guess). We don't know what's been done to Bergdahl--why is he being held to a different standard than the GOP's presidential nominee?

user-pic

I must admit that when I heard he was from Idaho I automatically thought that he is probably a white supremacist and a real right wing conservative, even though I felt so sorry for him seeing him in that video. He's so young. I kept wondering if his family is right winged and what they think about what this idiot Peters and Fox are saying about their son without any facts to support their statements. I am hoping maybe they might think twice before siding with the fox news types.

I hate to also admit that before this last election, I was more tolerant of others views, but I ashamedly have become very intolerant of others viewpoints because they seem so out of line with reality and decency.

user-pic

According to Wikipedia, this Ralph Peters seems more writer than soldier. Maybe his military record says the same: he did start off as enlisted, but retiring as a LtCol means he didn't blaze through the officer ranks. I suspect he has more opinions and mouth than knowledge or quality. Makes him a nice fit with Fox, huh?

user-pic

Ralph Peters is a columnist for the NY Post. He's been Murdoch's employee for who knows how long.

user-pic

I left this comment on Talking Points Memo on same subject-sorry if it is redundant but I need to comment again on this clown who calls himself a retired Army officer, who is paid as a "military analyst."

comment follows:

Peters makes me sick-I will not use his rank because he is not an officer, retired or otherwise in my book. I am a retired Regular Army officer (three trips to Vietnam) and I have never ever heard such garbage coming from anyone who served in the military-the first rule is take care of your troops-period, no exceptions, the second rule is leave no one behind-period, no exceptions. Peters obviously never served in combat and now he pontificates from the safety of his air conditioned office. These wing nut chicken hawks should make anyone who respects the flag and the people who serve nauseous-but that is what one expects from Fox, Glen Beck, who is "Batsh--" insane, O-Reilly, and Hannity. It seems that Michelle Malkin is even too disturbed to appear on the Fox channel anymore.

Soldier's family lives not far from in Idaho, small town, and to think that the family would hear this outrageous garbage from someone who professes to be a retired Army officer makes my gut churn.


user-pic

Seconded sir.

user-pic

This ballet student is also a paratrooper!

user-pic

Sounds like the premise for a new Fox sitcom!

user-pic

Even if Bergdahl did desert, doesn't he have rights under the military legal system? Why are these Fox people so quick to deny all that and say he should be executed? Aren't they the ones always going on about our brave service men and women fighting for our precious rights? Seems they don't really care about those rights after all.

user-pic

I read Peters' Wiki bio the other day. He enlisted after Vietnam in his late twenties. Can we say deferment? He served in Germany. We all know serving in Germany in the mid seventies was very scary and well, just like serving in the front lines in Vietnam.

user-pic

I would like to hear from the military that they are appalled at the way in which this retired a'hole has abandoned a fellow soldier to the Talibna. As one person above-noted, no one has th eright to judge whether a fellow soldier is worthy of resuce. He is a soldier in a combat zone and therefore any other soldier should support him and his return to base.

When they have him back to base, they can discuss how this all happened. Until this has been managed, there should be only one discussion. How to get him back.

user-pic

I doubt seriously that this soldier just dropped his weapon voluntarily and walked away. He's in a war zone--he would keep his weapon. Unless he was suffering from severe stress and acting irrationally. That wouldn't make him a coward, that would make him someone who needed medical attention. I don't understand FoxNew's eagerness to portray this young man as a coward unworthy of our concern. And I too would like to see the Defense Department speak up, because a captured soldier should not be put on trial on FoxNews as entertainment. That can't be good for our troops' morale.

user-pic

PFC Bowe Bergdahl is a captive in a war zone. We know that. The Army is not saying much and I credit them with having reasons for their silence. All military personnel are watching to see how this plays out, as it could conceivably apply if any of them were also captured.
All I know for sure about PFC Bergdahl is he volunteered for military service, and deserves respect for that act alone.
Rupert is only in it for the money. He could give a shit and says as much through his puppets. I hope peters enjoys his reward for his traitorous words.

user-pic

AS a soldier and officer:

A. Fox news guy is a disgrace to the uniform
B. Sounds like soldier was not doing what he was saposed to
C. I dosen't matter how much of an idiot the soldier was being... we leave no man behind.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe
Tip Line

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Zachary
Roth

Bio

Tag Cloud



Subscribe to this blog's feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address