TPMMuckraker

Motion To Stay Prop 8 Ruling Denied — But Judge Delays Lifting Stay

Motion To Stay Prop 8 Ruling Denied — But Judge Delays Lifting Stay

A federal judge in California today denied a motion to stay his ruling on Proposition 8, saying he will lift the temporary stay Aug. 18 at 5 p.m. Pacific time.

Judge Vaughn Walker ruled last week that Prop 8, which defined marriage in California as heterosexual, is unconstitutional. He issued a temporary stay — meaning same-sex couples can’t get married yet — and today ruled that his stay will continue until next Wednesday.

That will give the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the court which will hear the appeal of Prop 8 supporters, time to decide whether to issue its own stay.

“Any stay would serve only to delay plaintiffs access to the remedy to which they have shown they are entitled,” Walker said.

As in his original ruling, Walker wrote that proponents of Prop 8 just didn’t provide enough evidence for their position.

“Because proponents fail to satisfy any of the factors necessary to warrant a stay, the court
denies a stay except for a limited time solely in order to permit the court of appeals to consider the issue in an orderly manner,” Walker wrote in his ruling.

Walker pointed out that proponents of Prop 8 could not prove that they would suffer any harm if the stay is lifted. They argued that the state would be harmed but “proponents, of course, are not the state,” Walker said.

“Proponents also point to harm resulting from ‘a cloud of uncertainty’ surrounding the validity of marriages performed after judgment is entered but before proponents’ appeal is resolved. Proponents have not, however, alleged that any of them seek to wed a same-sex spouse,” he wrote.

The proponents also, he said, failed to prove that they were likely to succeed in their appeal. They might not even have standing to appeal, he argued, unless the original defendant — the state of California — agrees to appeal. And both the governor and the attorney general support same-sex marriage.

Here’s the ruling:

Prop 8: Final Stay Order

California, Gay Rights, Proposition 8, Same sex marriage

Editor & Publisher

Josh Marshall

Managing Editor

David Kurtz

Senior Associate Editor

Paul Werdel

Associate Editor

Sara Libby

Assistant Editor

Igor Bobic

Reporters

Brian Beutler

Carl Franzen

Sahil Kapur

Eric Kleefeld

Eric Lach

Nick Martin

Evan McMorris-Santoro

Ryan J. Reilly

Benjy Sarlin

Front Page Editor

David Taintor

Poll Editor

Kyle Leighton

News Writer

Pema Levy

Video Editor

Michael Lester

Polling Fellow

Tom Kludt

Video Fellow

Clayton Ashley

Research Interns

Michael Brooks

Publishing Intern

Christopher O’Driscoll

Miles Read

General Manager & General Counsel

Millet Israeli

VP, Ad Sales

Mary Cadwallader

Bob Edmunds

Bruce Ellerstein

Waldo Tibbetts

Manager, Ad Operations and Sales Support

Versha Sharma

Deputy Publisher

Callie Schweitzer

Director of Technology

Eric Buth

Designer/Developer

Ni Mu

Matthew Wozniak

Tech Fellow

Dennis Cahillane