TPMMuckraker

Hutaree Defense Lawyers Argue Militia Was Just A ‘Social Club’

Hutaree Defense Lawyers Argue Militia Was Just A ‘Social Club’

Opening arguments commenced this week in the trial of the seven members of the Hutaree Militia in Michigan, who are accused of plotting to kill police officers, but who defense attorneys argue were more of a “social club” than a serious threat.

The trial, which will likely last 6-8 weeks, kicked off Monday in Detroit with statements from Assistant U.S. Attorney Christopher Graveline, who is prosecuting the case, and three defense attorneys. On Tuesday, defense attorneys for other members of the militia will make opening statements as well.

The seven alleged militia members are accused of plotting to kill police officers, with one filing by the prosecution describing how they allegedly discussed “ambushing police officers, killing police officers during traffic stops, torching the homes of police officers and then shooting them and their families as they fled their burning homes.”

“These individuals, led by David Stone Sr., wanted an armed confrontation with law enforcement and the federal government,” Graveline said. “They wanted to start the war… patriots rising up against the government.”

David Ashenfelter of the Detroit Free Press, who attended the proceedings, reports that Graveline described how the members of the militia stockpiled firearms, ammunition and explosives, as well as bulletproof vests, suits used to disguise snipers and bomb-making instructions, and partook in military-style training. The evidence displayed by the prosecution included 20 weapons allegedly seized from the Hutaree, and 148,000 ammunition rounds.

“They were ready, willing and able to go to war,” Graveline said. “They practiced military-style exercises at David Stone Sr.’s home and other locations.”

William Swor, who is representing David Stone Sr., told the jury that “the fact of the matter is there is no ‘they,’ there is no ‘them.’”

“There was no plan and there was very little action,” he added, referencing how Stone believed that the apocalypse was coming. “David Stone did not pretend to know when this would happen,” Swor said. “So, David Stone began to prepare… He looked around for other people who were also looking to prepare. He talked to militia groups, he listened to militia groups and what he learned from them is that he didn’t want to belong to their groups for various reasons.”

Deputy Federal Defender Todd Shanker, who is representing David Stone, Jr. along with Deputy Federal Defender Richard Helfrick, told the jury that “these are not dark-hearted individuals. Raise your voices at the end of this case and find David Stone Jr. not guilty.”

“Calling this group a militia is pushing it,” Shanker said, the Detroit News reports. “It’s really a social club.”

Of the nine alleged members of the militia initially arrested in 2010, one, Joshua Clough, also known as “Azzurlin,” “Az” and “Mouse,” reached a plea agreement in December. Another was declared unfit to stand trial.

Hutaree, Michigan, Militia Movement, Militias
Jillian Rayfield

Jillian Rayfield is a Reporter/Blogger for TPM, and started as a News Intern in May 2009. She graduated from Cornell University in May 2008 with a degree in Film, and worked as a Research Assistant for a market research firm in London in between.

Editor & Publisher

Josh Marshall

Managing Editor

David Kurtz

Senior Associate Editor

Paul Werdel

Associate Editor

Sara Libby

Assistant Editor

Igor Bobic

Reporters

Brian Beutler

Carl Franzen

Sahil Kapur

Eric Kleefeld

Eric Lach

Nick Martin

Evan McMorris-Santoro

Ryan J. Reilly

Benjy Sarlin

Front Page Editor

David Taintor

Poll Editor

Kyle Leighton

News Writer

Pema Levy

Video Editor

Michael Lester

Polling Fellow

Tom Kludt

Video Fellow

Clayton Ashley

Research Interns

Michael Brooks

Publishing Intern

Christopher O’Driscoll

Miles Read

General Manager & General Counsel

Millet Israeli

VP, Ad Sales

Mary Cadwallader

Bob Edmunds

Bruce Ellerstein

Waldo Tibbetts

Manager, Ad Operations and Sales Support

Versha Sharma

Deputy Publisher

Callie Schweitzer

Director of Technology

Eric Buth

Designer/Developer

Ni Mu

Matthew Wozniak

Tech Fellow

Dennis Cahillane