« previous | MUCK HOME | next »

GOP: FISA's "Minimization" Procedures Can Protect Civil Liberties

The House Judiciary Committee hearing on FISA is just getting underway, but one GOP line of argument is clear even before Admiral McConnell finishes his opening statement. Both Lamar Smith (R-TX), the ranking GOP leader on the committee, and, more sharply, J. Randy Forbes (R-VA), said that it's unnecessary from a privacy perspective to require warrants for surveilling persons inside the U.S. when communicating with "known terrorists." (Incidentally, the Protect America Act isn't limited to surveilling "known terrorists" overseas without a warrant.) That's because the Justice Department's "minimization" procedures for discarding unlawfully-collected communications of U.S. citizens are sufficient -- and that it would be an impossible burden for the DOJ or the National Security Agency to tell the FISA Court that someone it seeks to monitor overseas might be communicating with people inside the United States.

What are those minimization procedures, under the new Protect America Act? We're waiting to hear, since McConnell's prepared testimony is vague on this question. Maybe that's why Chairman John Conyers (D-MI) swore in McConnell and Assistant Attorney General Kenneth Wainstein.

Here's Randy Forbes:


Comments (2)

jeffgee wrote on September 18, 2007 1:35 PM:

Randy and Lamar- please define "known terrorists". Is a blog posting enough to get on the list?

internetjoe wrote on September 18, 2007 6:18 PM:

The known terrorists are everyone but the 25% Bush Dead Enders - so any communication anywhere can be -collected-.

They are saying that they broke the law as did the Telcos , Why a need for freeing ATT from liability if there was no law broken?

OH the FBI and NSA twisted the arms of the telcos so they had to give in.

Sure -
Minimization
Sounds like a Lame Ass remake of
Fantastic Voyage
Not a method of Protecting the maybe one freedom i have left.

Post a comment

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address