TPMMuckraker
pension scandals

Marc Correra: The Link Between New York's Pension Scandal And "Toxic Waste" In New Mexico?

Moe Tkacik | May 1, 2009, 4:59PM

Three weeks ago we told you about accusations that the New Mexico State Investment Council had been under political pressure to invest teachers' retirement funds in risky investments like a $90 million "toxic waste" CDO backed by subprime mortgages -- and wondered if any of the other intensifying corruption investigations across the country might involve some of the same pay-for-players.

Sure enough, a few names emerged last week to link the New Mexico pension fund scandal to the alleged conspiracy to defraud the New York general pension fund under investigation by the state attorney general's office. One was Obama car czar Steve Rattner, who paid alleged ringleader Hank Morris more than a million dollars for securing investments in both states' pension funds. Morris was indicted in March for collecting $30 million in fraudulent "finder's fees" as a top adviser to the former state comptroller Alan Hevesi, in collusion with the pension fund's manager David Loglisci. But the indictment didn't address Morris's "placement" services in other states; his name turned up on a list of placement agents released by the New Mexico State Investment Council as the broker of a $20 million investment in Rattner's private equity firm Quadrangle.

The other thread running through both the New York and New Mexico pension funds was the advisory firm Aldus Equity, whose founder Saul Meyer was charged yesterday with participating in the New York conspiracy and which also until this week advised similar investments in New Mexico.

The further we looked, the wider and farther-back the suspicions of public pension fund pay-to-play seemed to extend, as Cuomo noted himself at yesterday's press conference:

PERMALINK | COMMENTS (6) | RECOMMEND RECOMMEND (17)
Topics: Aldus Equity, Bill Richardson, Dan Weinstein, Jerry Cremins, Marc Correra, pension scandals

CDR

The Pension Scandals: Six Degrees Of How "Toxic Waste" Lands In Teachers' Retirement Funds

Moe Tkacik | April 29, 2009, 3:31PM

LATE UPDATE: An earlier version of this post misidentified New Mexico State Investment Council portfolio manager Kay Chippeaux as being Frank Foy's replacement; Foy had held various titles including chief investment officer at the state's Education Retirement Board.

In June 1997 Tom Flanigan, the chief investment officer of the California State Teachers Retirement System, wrote a letter to his old mentor, then-SEC chief Arthur Levitt. He was under political pressure, he said, to gamble with teachers' savings. The state comptroller was demanding he allocate a bigger portion of the fund to venture capital firms and hedge funds in what he thought to be an overheated market.

Meanwhile, hedge funds and private equity firms were hiring politically connected "placement agents" to descend upon his board of directors, who had final approval over his investment decisions. He had just watched the Texas investment firm Hicks, Muse, Tate and Furst secure a $100 million investment from the state employees' general retirement fund CalPERS after paying a $750,000 "finders fee" to a former board member and longtime Los Angeles politico named Alfred Villalobos. Villalobos had a questionable history with Hicks -- as a board member he'd already approved another $100 million investment in the firm on the advice of the fund's paid adviser Chris Bower. Nine months later, Bower sold his two-year-old yacht to Hicks founder Tom Hicks for a $45,000 profit. And there was other smoke around the deal, if no clear fire: Villalobo, for one had just filed for personal bankruptcy over gambling debts. And the board had initially rejected the deal -- when another LA politico on the board, a labor leader named Jerry Cremins, changed their minds. There was something "unseemly if not unethical" going on, Flanigan wrote. The SEC proposed rules regulating the placement agencies.

A few months later, Flanigan was sacked.